Ma · Mathematics

What Does the Symbol ⊂⊂ Mean?

Published By the 9to5Science editorial team

At a glance

  1. 1. Read the context

    In analysis, ⊂⊂ usually denotes compact containment, not just an ordinary subset relation.

  2. 2. Take the closure

    Check whether the closure of the smaller set is compact and remains inside the larger set.

  3. 3. Check the convention

    Authors may define the notation differently, so use the definition given in the text.

Advertisement

In complex analysis and harmonic analysis, the notation U⊂⊂VU \subset\subset V usually says that UU is compactly contained in VV. For sets in the complex plane or Euclidean space, this normally means that the closure of UU is a compact subset of VV:

U⊂⊂V⟺U‾ is compact and U‾⊂V.U \subset\subset V \quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad \overline{U}\text{ is compact and }\overline{U}\subset V.

The notation is also written U⋐VU\Subset V, and the phrase relatively compact in VV is often used for the same idea. Since conventions vary, look for a definition in the text when precision matters.

What compact containment adds

An ordinary inclusion U⊂VU\subset V only says that every point of UU belongs to VV. Compact containment also requires UU to stay away from the edge of VV in the usual settings of analysis: its closure must fit entirely inside VV and must be compact.

For example, if UU and VV are open subsets of Rn\mathbb{R}^n or C\mathbb{C}, the condition is that U‾\overline U be a compact set contained in VV. In Euclidean space, compactness is equivalent to being closed and bounded, so the condition can be checked by verifying both that UU is bounded and that its closure does not reach outside VV.

Compact containment is useful when a proof needs room around a smaller region. A function or estimate can be studied on a set whose boundary stays inside the larger domain, rather than right at the domain’s boundary.

A worked example with disks

Let D(0,r)={z∈C:∣z∣<r}D(0,r)=\{z\in\mathbb C:|z|<r\} be the open disk of radius rr centered at the origin. Then

D(0,1)⊂⊂D(0,2).D(0,1)\subset\subset D(0,2).

To check it, take the closure of the smaller disk:

D(0,1)‾={z:∣z∣≤1}.\overline{D(0,1)}=\{z:|z|\leq 1\}.

This closed disk is bounded, so it is compact in C\mathbb C. It is also contained in D(0,2)D(0,2) because every point in it has modulus at most 11, which is strictly less than 22. Thus the compact-containment condition holds.

By contrast,

D(0,2)⊄⊂D(0,2),D(0,2)\not\subset\subset D(0,2),

under the usual open-set convention. Its closure is the closed disk {z:∣z∣≤2}\{z:|z|\leq 2\}, which includes points on the boundary of the open disk and therefore is not contained in D(0,2)D(0,2). Although D(0,2)⊂D(0,2)D(0,2)\subset D(0,2) is true, the stronger compact-containment statement is not.

How to interpret it in a proof

If a text says “choose U⋐VU\Subset V,” read this as choosing a smaller region UU whose closure fits compactly inside VV. In a typical argument with open sets in Rn\mathbb{R}^n, check these points:

  1. UU is inside VV.
  2. The closure U‾\overline U is still inside VV, not merely touching its boundary.
  3. U‾\overline U is compact. In Euclidean space, this means it is closed and bounded.

The notation does not specify a particular distance between the two boundaries. In Euclidean space, when U‾\overline U is compact and lies inside an open set VV, there is a positive distance between U‾\overline U and the complement of VV (assuming that complement is nonempty). The size of that distance depends on the sets.

Common mistakes

  • Treating it as an ordinary subset symbol. Compact containment is stronger than U⊂VU\subset V; the closure matters.
  • Checking only that UU is bounded. A bounded set may approach or cross the boundary of VV. You must also verify U‾⊂V\overline U\subset V.
  • Assuming a universal convention. Some authors define U⋐VU\Subset V explicitly, and usages can differ, especially outside familiar Euclidean settings. Follow the author’s definition.
  • Confusing the mathematical notation with its LaTeX spelling. Writing \subset\subset produces two subset symbols side by side. The single command \Subset is also available with the amssymb package, but the choice of glyph does not by itself establish what the author means.

Spotted an error? Send a correction. Read how we write and check articles in our editorial policy.