Why the Points at Distance 1 from a Compact Set Have Measure Zero
At a glance
- 1. Define the distance
Let K be a nonempty compact subset of Euclidean space and consider points x with distance from K exactly 1.
- 2. Use differentiability
The distance function is Lipschitz, so it is differentiable almost everywhere.
- 3. Compare gradients
At a density point of the level set, its gradient must be zero; outside K, a differentiable distance function has gradient norm 1.
- 4. Conclude measure zero
The two gradient facts contradict each other if the level set has positive measure.
Title: Why the Points at Distance 1 from a Compact Set Have Measure Zero Category: mathematics
Let be a nonempty compact subset of , and define its distance function by
The set in question is the level set
We will show that has -dimensional Lebesgue measure zero. The argument uses two standard facts: distance functions are Lipschitz, and Lipschitz functions are differentiable almost everywhere.
The distance function is Lipschitz
For any , the triangle inequality gives
Interchanging and shows that . Thus is 1-Lipschitz. By Rademacher’s theorem, it is differentiable at almost every point of .
Compactness ensures that every point has a nearest point satisfying . In fact, a nearest point also exists for any nonempty closed subset of finite-dimensional Euclidean space, but compactness is enough here.
The gradient has norm 1 where distance is positive
Suppose and that is differentiable at . Choose a nearest point , and set , a unit vector. For , the point lies on the segment from toward . Its distance from is at most its distance from :
The 1-Lipschitz property also gives . Therefore equality holds. Taking the directional derivative in direction gives
So . On the other hand, a differentiable 1-Lipschitz function has gradient norm at most 1. Hence
In particular, this holds at every differentiability point of the level set , since its points have distance 1 from .
Why a positive-measure level set is impossible
Assume, for contradiction, that has positive Lebesgue measure. The Lebesgue density theorem says that almost every point of is a density point: near such a point, the proportion of a small ball occupied by tends to 1. Rademacher’s theorem says that is differentiable almost everywhere. Thus there is a point that is both a density point of and a differentiability point of .
At a density point of a level set, the derivative of a differentiable function that is constant on that level set must be zero. To see the idea, take any direction . At small scale , a density-one set comes arbitrarily close to the point relative to the scale . Thus there are points with . Since , differentiability implies . This holds for every , so .
But the previous section showed that at every differentiability point of . This contradiction proves
The proof establishes the claim for every fixed positive distance, not just distance 1: for any , the level set has Lebesgue measure zero.
A concrete example
Let be the closed disk of radius 2 centered at the origin in . For a point outside the disk, its distance to is . Therefore the points at distance exactly 1 form the circle
A circle has two-dimensional Lebesgue measure zero, even though it has infinitely many points. The theorem shows that the same zero-area conclusion holds for much more irregular compact sets, including ones with no smooth boundary.
In one dimension, the result also has a simple description. The complement of a closed subset of is a union of disjoint open intervals, and there are at most countably many such intervals. Within each bounded gap, the points at a fixed positive distance from the set are the two points at distance from the endpoints if the gap has length greater than , the midpoint if its length is exactly , and no points if its length is less than . On an unbounded gap there is at most one such point. The level set is therefore countable and has measure zero.
Common mistakes
- Confusing a level set with a neighborhood. The set of points at distance at most 1 can have positive measure; the result concerns points at distance exactly 1.
- Assuming the level set is finite or countable in every dimension. It can contain a whole circle or other large lower-dimensional sets. The conclusion is zero -dimensional measure, not few points.
- Using compactness without identifying its role. Compactness guarantees nearest points exist. The proof also works for any nonempty closed set in finite-dimensional Euclidean space, since nearest points exist there as well.
References
- Real Analysis: Modern Techniques and Their Applications, Gerald B. Folland
- Measure Theory and Fine Properties of Functions, Lawrence C. Evans and Ronald F. Gariepy
Spotted an error? Send a correction. Read how we write and check articles in our editorial policy.