Do Rational Open Intervals Generate the Borel Sigma Algebra on R?
At a glance
- 1. Check the generators
Every open interval with rational endpoints is open, so it belongs to the Borel sigma algebra.
- 2. Use the countable base
Rational-endpoint intervals form a countable base for the usual topology on the real line.
- 3. Write opens as unions
Each open set is a union of base intervals contained in it, and this union is countable.
- 4. Conclude equality
Both generated sigma algebras contain each other, so they are equal.
Let , the family of bounded open intervals with rational endpoints. The claim is that the sigma algebra generated by is the Borel sigma algebra on :
The key fact is that these intervals form a countable base for the usual topology on the real line. The proof checks the two inclusions. The same result holds if the stated family also includes unbounded intervals with rational endpoints.
What the Borel sigma algebra is
The Borel sigma algebra is the smallest sigma algebra containing every open subset of . A sigma algebra is closed under complements and countable unions (and therefore countable intersections).
The notation means the smallest sigma algebra containing every interval in . To prove two sigma algebras are equal, show each is contained in the other.
First inclusion:
Every interval in is open. By definition, every open set is Borel, so every member of belongs to .
Since is a sigma algebra containing all the generators, it must contain the sigma algebra they generate. Thus
Second inclusion:
Take any open set . For every , openness gives some such that . By the density of the rationals, choose rational numbers such that
Then , with . Consequently, is the union of all rational-endpoint intervals contained in it:
There are only countably many rational pairs , so this is a countable union. Since every interval in the union belongs to , closure under countable unions gives .
Thus every open set belongs to . The latter is a sigma algebra containing all open sets, so it contains the Borel sigma algebra:
Combining the inclusions proves the equality.
Example: an open interval with irrational endpoints
Consider . Its endpoints are not rational, but it can still be written as a union of intervals from :
Every interval on the right lies inside . Conversely, if lies in , density of the rationals lets you choose with , so belongs to one of those intervals. The indexing set is countable because it is a subset of .
This shows why rational endpoints suffice: open sets need not themselves be single generators; they can be countable unions of generators.
Common mistakes
- Trying to match endpoints exactly. An open interval with irrational endpoints need not be one of the generators. It is enough to express it as a countable union of rational-endpoint intervals.
- Using an arbitrary union without checking countability. A sigma algebra is guaranteed to be closed under countable unions, not arbitrary unions. Here countability follows from the fact that is countable.
- Proving only that the generators are Borel. That gives just one inclusion. The countable-base argument is needed for the reverse inclusion.
- Thinking the rational endpoints must include every real endpoint. Their role is to provide intervals small enough to fit around each point of any open set.
The result is a general topological principle: a countable base for a topology generates the Borel sigma algebra of that topology.
References
- Measure Theory — Paul R. Halmos
- Topology — James R. Munkres
Spotted an error? Send a correction. Read how we write and check articles in our editorial policy.