Why Is the One-Point Compactification Unique Up to Homeomorphism?
At a glance
- 1. Fix the assumptions
Take a noncompact, locally compact Hausdorff space X and a compactification whose remainder contains exactly one point.
- 2. Identify neighborhoods
A neighborhood of the added point has compact complement in X; conversely, every compact subset of X gives such a neighborhood.
- 3. Match the topologies
This neighborhood rule is the same for every one-point compactification of X.
- 4. Extend the identity
Map each point of X to itself and one added point to the other; the matching neighborhood rules make this a homeomorphism.
A one-point compactification adds a single point, often written ∞, to a noncompact space X so that the enlarged space is compact. The uniqueness claim means more than that two such spaces happen to be homeomorphic: there is a homeomorphism that leaves every point of X fixed and sends one added point to the other.
The standard assumptions are that X is locally compact, Hausdorff, and noncompact. Under these assumptions, the one-point compactification exists, and its topology is determined by the compact subsets of X.
The topology at the added point
Write X* = X ∪ {∞}. The open sets that do not contain ∞ are just the open subsets of X. A set containing ∞ is open precisely when its complement is a compact subset of X. Thus an open neighborhood of ∞ has the form
where K is compact in X.
This condition captures the idea that approaching ∞ means leaving every compact part of X. For example, in the one-point compactification of the real line, the set consisting of ∞ together with all real numbers outside [-2, 3] is a neighborhood of ∞: its complement is the compact interval [-2, 3].
Why every one-point compactification has this topology
Suppose Y is any compact Hausdorff compactification of X whose remainder consists of one point p. Identify X with its image in Y. Since Y is Hausdorff, the singleton {p} is closed, so X = Y \ {p} is open in Y.
Now consider an open neighborhood V of p in Y. Its complement Y \ V is closed in the compact space Y, and therefore compact. It does not contain p, so it is a compact subset of X.
Conversely, let K be any compact subset of X. Its image in Y is compact. A compact subset of a Hausdorff space is closed, so K is closed in Y. Therefore Y \ K is an open neighborhood of p.
Together, these two directions show that the open neighborhoods of p are exactly the complements of compact subsets of X. The topology on X itself is already fixed by the requirement that Y compactify X. Hence the entire topology of Y is determined by X and the rule for open neighborhoods of its added point.
Constructing the homeomorphism
Let X*_1 and X*_2 be two one-point compactifications, with added points p_1 and p_2. Define a map h by
The map is a bijection. It is continuous on X because it is the identity there. At p_1, the neighborhood description above shows that every open neighborhood has compact complement in X; the corresponding complement defines an open neighborhood of p_2 as well. Thus h is continuous at the added point. The same argument applies to the inverse map, so h is a homeomorphism.
In fact, this map is the unique homeomorphism that fixes X pointwise: once all points of X are fixed, the only remaining point has to map to the only remaining point.
A concrete example: compactifying the real line
Suppose Y_1 and Y_2 are two one-point compactifications of the real line, with added points ∞_1 and ∞_2. The map that sends each real number r to itself and ∞_1 to ∞_2 is a homeomorphism.
For instance, the set {∞_1} ∪ ((−∞, −2) ∪ (3, ∞)) is open in Y_1 because its complement is the compact interval [-2, 3]. The corresponding set with ∞_2 is open in Y_2 for exactly the same reason. This works for every compact complement, not just this interval, so the map matches all open neighborhoods of the added point.
Common mistakes and scope
- Omitting the hypotheses: Local compactness and the Hausdorff condition are part of the standard theorem. Without them, the usual construction may fail to give a compact Hausdorff space, or the uniqueness statement may require a different formulation.
- Requiring neighborhoods to be complements of open sets: The defining complement is compact in X. In a Hausdorff space, compact subsets are closed, but the definition is about compactness, not merely closedness.
- Claiming the added point itself is always open: It is open only when X is compact, which is excluded in the standard definition. For a noncompact X, the complement of the singleton ∞ is X, which is not compact, so {∞} is not open.
- Confusing uniqueness with identical labels: The added points in two constructions need not be the same set-theoretic object. The canonical homeomorphism identifies them while fixing X.
If X is compact, the standard one-point compactification construction is not used: adding an extra point does not produce a compactification in which X is dense with the usual neighborhood rule. The noncompact hypothesis avoids this degenerate case.
References
- James R. Munkres, Topology
- Stephen Willard, General Topology
Spotted an error? Send a correction. Read how we write and check articles in our editorial policy.