Ma · Mathematics

Show That the Stone–Čech Compactification βℤ Is Not Metrizable

Published By the 9to5Science editorial team

At a glance

  1. 1. Use discrete subsets

    Every subset of discrete ℤ has a continuous characteristic function with values in {0,1}.

  2. 2. Extend to βℤ

    The Stone–Čech property extends each characteristic function continuously to the compactification.

  3. 3. Count clopen sets

    Distinct subsets of ℤ give distinct clopen subsets of βℤ, so there are uncountably many.

  4. 4. Compare with metric spaces

    A compact metric space has a countable base and therefore only countably many clopen subsets.

Assume that Z\mathbb{Z} has the discrete topology, as is standard when writing βZ\beta\mathbb{Z}. The key is to compare the number of clopen subsets of βZ\beta\mathbb{Z} with the number possible in a compact metric space. The Stone–Čech extension property gives βZ\beta\mathbb{Z} far too many clopen sets for it to be metrizable.

The key idea

For every subset AA of Z\mathbb{Z}, its characteristic function

χA(n)={1,n∈A,0,n∉A\chi_A(n)= \begin{cases} 1,&n\in A,\\ 0,&n\notin A \end{cases}

is continuous from discrete Z\mathbb{Z} to the two-point discrete space {0,1}\{0,1\}. By the defining extension property of the Stone–Čech compactification, this function extends to a continuous function χA~:βZ→{0,1}\widetilde{\chi_A}:\beta\mathbb{Z}\to\{0,1\}.

The inverse image χA~−1({1})\widetilde{\chi_A}^{-1}(\{1\}) is clopen: {1}\{1\} is both open and closed in {0,1}\{0,1\}, and continuous inverse images preserve both properties. Moreover, this clopen set intersects Z\mathbb{Z} exactly in AA, because the extension agrees with χA\chi_A on Z\mathbb{Z}. Thus different subsets AA give different clopen subsets of βZ\beta\mathbb{Z}.

There are uncountably many subsets of Z\mathbb{Z}. So βZ\beta\mathbb{Z} has uncountably many clopen subsets.

Why a compact metric space has only countably many clopen sets

Every compact metric space is second countable: it has a countable base B\mathcal{B} of open sets. Let CC be any clopen subset. It is compact, since it is closed in a compact space. For each point of CC, choose a basis element containing that point and contained in CC. These basis elements cover CC. Compactness gives a finite subcover, so CC is a finite union of elements of B\mathcal{B}.

There are only countably many finite collections of elements of a countable base. Hence there can be only countably many such finite unions, and therefore only countably many clopen subsets.

This applies to any compact metric space, not just to βZ\beta\mathbb{Z}. If βZ\beta\mathbb{Z} were metrizable, its compactness would force it to have only countably many clopen subsets. The extension argument shows it has uncountably many. The contradiction proves that βZ\beta\mathbb{Z} is not metrizable.

A concrete example

Take AA to be the even integers. The function that is 1 on even integers and 0 on odd integers extends continuously from Z\mathbb{Z} to βZ\beta\mathbb{Z}. The inverse image of {1}\{1\} under that extension is a clopen subset of βZ\beta\mathbb{Z} whose intersection with the embedded copy of Z\mathbb{Z} is precisely the even integers.

Now do the same for the odd integers, or for any other subset, such as the multiples of 3. The resulting clopen subsets are distinct whenever the original subsets of Z\mathbb{Z} are distinct: their intersections with Z\mathbb{Z} differ. This illustrates how every subset—not only familiar arithmetic subsets—produces a separate clopen set.

Common mistakes

  • Using uncountability of βZ\beta\mathbb{Z} alone. An uncountable compact metric space can exist; for example, the interval [0,1][0,1] is one. The contradiction requires the stronger fact that βZ\beta\mathbb{Z} has uncountably many clopen subsets.
  • Assuming a countable dense subset rules out metrizability. It does not. Compact metric spaces are separable, and some have countable dense subsets. The fact that Z\mathbb{Z} is countable and dense in βZ\beta\mathbb{Z} is not enough to settle the question.
  • Forgetting the topology on Z\mathbb{Z}. The argument uses the discrete topology, which makes every characteristic function continuous. βZ\beta\mathbb{Z} conventionally denotes the Stone–Čech compactification of Z\mathbb{Z} with this topology.
  • Treating the extension as automatically a {0,1}\{0,1\}-valued function without justification. The extension property can be applied directly with {0,1}\{0,1\} as its compact Hausdorff target. Its extension therefore takes values in {0,1}\{0,1\}, so the inverse image used above is clopen.

The proof depends only on the extension property and the countability of a metric space’s base. The same argument works for the Stone–Čech compactification βD\beta D of any infinite discrete space DD: every subset of DD yields a distinct clopen subset of βD\beta D, so βD\beta D is not metrizable.

References

  1. General Topology — John L. Kelley
  2. Rings of Continuous Functions — Leonard Gillman and Meyer Jerison

Spotted an error? Send a correction. Read how we write and check articles in our editorial policy.