Ma · Mathematics

What Is the Universal Property of Ring and Module Completions?

Published By the 9to5Science editorial team

At a glance

  1. 1. Choose a filtration

    For an ideal I, use the quotients R/Iⁿ for rings and M/IⁿM for modules.

  2. 2. Form the inverse limit

    The completion consists of compatible residue classes, with its inverse-limit topology.

  3. 3. Check continuity

    A map extends when it respects the filtrations and its target is complete and separated.

  4. 4. Extend by limits

    Approximate a completed element by original elements and take the limit of their images.

  5. 5. Use density for uniqueness

    The original ring or module is dense in its completion, so a continuous extension is unique.

Advertisement

Let II be an ideal of a ring RR, and let MM be an RR-module. Their II-adic completions are

R^=lim←⁡n≥1R/In,M^=lim←⁡n≥1M/InM.\widehat R=\varprojlim_{n\ge 1} R/I^n, \qquad \widehat M=\varprojlim_{n\ge 1} M/I^nM.

The inverse limits come with natural topologies: neighborhoods of zero are the kernels of the projections to the finite quotients. The universal property says that continuous maps into complete, separated objects extend uniquely across the completion. Both the topology and the continuity condition matter; this is not a universal property in the category of ordinary rings or modules with no topology specified.

The module universal property

Give MM its II-adic topology, whose neighborhoods of zero are InMI^nM. Suppose NN is an RR-module that is complete and separated for this topology, meaning that

N≅lim←⁡n≥1N/InN.N\cong\varprojlim_{n\ge 1}N/I^nN.

Then every RR-linear map f:M→Nf:M\to N extends uniquely to a continuous map

f^:M^→N.\widehat f:\widehat M\to N.

Because ff is RR-linear, f(InM)⊆InNf(I^nM)\subseteq I^nN, so it is continuous for the II-adic topologies. The extended map is linear over R^\widehat R when NN is given the natural action of R^\widehat R induced by its completeness.

More generally, the same extension statement works for a continuous map between filtered modules, provided the target is complete and separated. The filtration conditions may differ from the specific II-adic ones above.

Why the extension exists and is unique

An element x∈M^x\in\widehat M is a compatible sequence of residue classes modulo InMI^nM. Since MM maps densely into M^\widehat M, choose elements xn∈Mx_n\in M that approximate xx increasingly closely. The sequence (xn)(x_n) is Cauchy in the II-adic topology: for each fixed kk, its terms eventually agree modulo IkMI^kM.

Continuity of ff makes (f(xn))(f(x_n)) Cauchy in NN. Completeness gives a limit, and define

f^(x)=lim⁡n→∞f(xn).\widehat f(x)=\lim_{n\to\infty} f(x_n).

If a different approximating sequence is chosen, the differences between corresponding terms tend to zero in the filtration. Their images therefore tend to zero, so the limit is unchanged. This proves the extension is well-defined. It agrees with ff on MM.

For uniqueness, any continuous extension must take the same value on the dense subset MM as ff. Since NN is separated, two continuous maps agreeing on a dense subset agree everywhere.

The ring version

Apply the same idea to rings, using the II-adic topology on RR and the JJ-adic topology on a target ring SS. If SS is complete and separated for the JJ-adic topology, and a ring homomorphism f:R→Sf:R\to S satisfies

f(I)⊆J,f(I)\subseteq J,

then f(In)⊆Jnf(I^n)\subseteq J^n for every nn. Thus ff is continuous and extends uniquely to a continuous ring homomorphism

f^:R^ I→S^ J=S.\widehat f:\widehat R^{\,I}\to\widehat S^{\,J}=S.

Here the superscript indicates which ideal defines the completion. The condition on f(I)f(I) is a convenient sufficient condition for continuity; the essential requirement is that the map respect the chosen topologies.

This explains the usual formulation: completion is universal for maps from the original ring or module to complete separated objects, as long as those maps are continuous. Without continuity, an extension need not exist. Without separatedness, uniqueness need not hold.

Worked example: the pp-adic integers

Take R=ZR=\mathbb Z and I=(p)I=(p) for a prime pp. Then

Z^ (p)=lim←⁡nZ/pnZ=Zp,\widehat{\mathbb Z}^{\,(p)}=\varprojlim_n\mathbb Z/p^n\mathbb Z=\mathbb Z_p,

the ring of pp-adic integers. If AA is a ring complete and separated for the ideals pnAp^nA, the identity-on-integers map Z→A\mathbb Z\to A is continuous: multiples of pnp^n map into pnAp^nA. Consequently there is a unique continuous unital ring homomorphism

Zp→A\mathbb Z_p\to A

that extends n↦n⋅1An\mapsto n\cdot 1_A. In practical terms, a pp-adic integer is approximated by ordinary integers modulo successively higher powers of pp, and their images in AA converge to the required value.

For modules, let NN be a pp-adically complete separated abelian group. A homomorphism f:Z→Nf:\mathbb Z\to N is determined by f(1)f(1). The unique extension Zp→N\mathbb Z_p\to N sends a∈Zpa\in\mathbb Z_p to the limit of akf(1)a_k f(1), where integers aka_k approach aa modulo pkp^k.

Common mistakes

  • Ignoring topology: The universal property does not claim that every algebraic map extends. The map must be continuous for the filtrations being used.
  • Forgetting separatedness: Completeness supplies limits; separatedness ensures limits are unique and hence the extension is unique.
  • Confusing two completions: Completing a target ring along JJ and completing the source along II are different operations. The map must carry the source filtration into the target filtration.
  • Assuming every notion of completion agrees: The inverse-limit topology on M^\widehat M is the one used in the universal property. Under additional hypotheses, such as common noetherian and finite-generation assumptions, it behaves especially well with the filtration InM^I^n\widehat M; without such hypotheses, these filtrations should not be silently identified.

References

  1. Introduction to Commutative Algebra — Michael Atiyah and Ian G. Macdonald, Chapter 10

Spotted an error? Send a correction. Read how we write and check articles in our editorial policy.