Why Can’t the Complex Numbers Be an Ordered Field?
At a glance
- 1. Use ordered-field rules
An ordered field has a total order compatible with addition and multiplication.
- 2. Squares are nonnegative
Every element squared is nonnegative, and every nonzero element squared is positive.
- 3. Apply this to i
Since i is nonzero, i² must be positive; but i² equals −1, which is negative.
- 4. Conclude contradiction
Therefore no order compatible with the field operations makes C an ordered field.
The complex numbers cannot be made into an ordered field: the field operations force a contradiction with the rules every ordered field must satisfy. The key fact is that the square of any nonzero element in an ordered field is positive. But the complex number satisfies .
What “ordered field” means
An ordered field is a field equipped with a total order that works consistently with addition and multiplication. In particular:
- If , then for every .
- If and , then .
- Any two distinct elements are comparable: one is less than the other.
The second rule says that the product of positive elements is positive. These conditions are stronger than merely putting the elements in some sequence. They require the order to respect the field’s arithmetic.
Why every nonzero square is positive
Take any nonzero element in an ordered field. Totality says either or .
If , multiplying by itself gives . If , then , so . But , again giving . Thus
In particular, is positive because and . Its additive inverse is therefore negative: .
The contradiction from
Suppose, for contradiction, that some total order makes an ordered field. The imaginary unit is nonzero, so the square rule requires
However, the defining relation for is
And because , its additive inverse satisfies . The same number, , would have to be both positive and negative. That is impossible in a total order. Hence no order compatible with the usual addition and multiplication makes an ordered field.
This argument does not depend on choosing a familiar way to compare complex numbers. It rules out every possible order that obeys the ordered-field rules.
A concrete check
The contradiction can be written as a short chain of requirements:
- Since , an ordered field requires .
- Since , this says .
- Since , multiplying by or taking the additive inverse gives .
The second and third statements cannot both hold. The problem is not that is “imaginary” or hard to compare with real numbers; it is that its square is a negative number.
Common mistakes
Assuming the usual geometric picture settles the question. A complex number can be represented by a point in the plane, but the plane’s usual geometry does not provide a field order. The proof must address whether an order can be compatible with both arithmetic operations.
Trying to decide whether is positive or negative. You do not need to choose. If , then . If , then and . Either possibility conflicts with .
Using an order that respects addition but not multiplication. For instance, one can compare complex numbers lexicographically by their real and then imaginary parts. That gives a total order compatible with addition, but it is not a field order: it has , while . In an ordered field, a positive number multiplied by itself must be positive.
The broader rule
The same reasoning applies in any ordered field: no negative element can be a square. Therefore a field containing a square root of cannot be ordered as a field. The real numbers satisfy this restriction, while the complex numbers do not. This is why is an ordered field but is not.
Spotted an error? Send a correction. Read how we write and check articles in our editorial policy.