Ma · Mathematics

How Are the Quaternion Group Q₈ and Dihedral Group D₈ Different?

Published By the 9to5Science editorial team

At a glance

  1. 1. Identify the convention

    Here D₈ means the symmetry group of a square, which has eight elements.

  2. 2. Compare element orders

    Q₈ has one element of order 2; D₈ has five.

  3. 3. Rule out isomorphism

    An isomorphism preserves element orders, so these groups cannot be isomorphic.

  4. 4. Compare shared structure

    Both groups are nonabelian of order 8, with a center of order 2 and quotient isomorphic to V₄.

The quaternion group Q8Q_8 and the dihedral group D8D_8 are two different nonabelian groups of order 88. They share several properties, which can make them seem similar, but their element orders give a quick way to tell them apart.

Here, D8D_8 means the symmetries of a square: four rotations and four reflections. Some books use D4D_4 for this group, naming it by the number of vertices rather than the number of elements. Always check the convention being used.

Definitions and presentations

The quaternion group is

Q8={1,−1,i,−i,j,−j,k,−k},Q_8=\{1,-1,i,-i,j,-j,k,-k\},

with multiplication rules i2=j2=k2=ijk=−1i^2=j^2=k^2=ijk=-1. In particular, i2=j2=k2=−1i^2=j^2=k^2=-1, and −1-1 is the identity’s only other element of order 22.

The square’s dihedral group can be presented as

D8=⟨r,s∣r4=1, s2=1, srs=r−1⟩.D_8=\langle r,s\mid r^4=1,\ s^2=1,\ srs=r^{-1}\rangle.

Here, rr is a quarter-turn and ss is a reflection. Its elements are 1,r,r2,r3,s,sr,sr2,sr31,r,r^2,r^3,s,sr,sr^2,sr^3. Every element can be written as either rmr^m or srmsr^m for m=0,1,2,3m=0,1,2,3.

Both groups have order 88 and are nonabelian. For example, in D8D_8, a reflection does not commute with a quarter-turn; in Q8Q_8, ij=kij=k but ji=−kji=-k.

The key difference: elements of order 2

An element has order 22 if it is not the identity and its square is the identity.

In Q8Q_8, each of i,j,k,−i,−j,−ki,j,k,-i,-j,-k squares to −1-1, not to 11. Thus the only element of order 22 is −1-1:

{x∈Q8:x2=1}={1,−1}.\{x\in Q_8: x^2=1\}=\{1,-1\}.

In D8D_8, the half-turn r2r^2 has order 22. Each reflection also has order 22, since s2=1s^2=1 and conjugating a reflection by a rotation gives another reflection. There are four reflections, so the five elements of order 22 are

r2,s,sr,sr2,sr3.r^2,\quad s,\quad sr,\quad sr^2,\quad sr^3.

The identity is not counted as an element of order 22.

PropertyQ8Q_8D8D_8
Number of elements88
Elements of order 215
Elements of order 462
Abelian?NoNo

Why this proves the groups are not isomorphic

An isomorphism preserves element orders. If f:G→Hf:G\to H is an isomorphism and xx has order nn, then f(x)n=f(xn)=1f(x)^n=f(x^n)=1. Because ff is bijective and preserves the group operation, f(x)f(x) has the same order as xx.

Consequently, an isomorphism would give a one-to-one correspondence between the elements of order 22 in the two groups. But Q8Q_8 has one such element and D8D_8 has five. Therefore,

Q8≇D8.Q_8\not\cong D_8.

This is a complete distinction: you do not need to compare every possible multiplication table or search for a particular map.

A worked check using squares

You can verify the counts directly from the group descriptions.

For Q8Q_8, the six elements ±i,±j,±k\pm i,\pm j,\pm k all square to −1-1, while 12=(−1)2=11^2=(-1)^2=1. So exactly two elements satisfy x2=1x^2=1, one of which is the identity. That leaves one element of order 22.

For D8D_8, the rotations satisfy (rm)2=r2m(r^m)^2=r^{2m}. Among 1,r,r2,r31,r,r^2,r^3, only 11 and r2r^2 square to 11. Each reflection srmsr^m squares to the identity:

(srm)2=srmsrm=r−mrm=1.(sr^m)^2=sr^msr^m=r^{-m}r^m=1.

There are four reflections. Altogether, six elements of D8D_8 square to 11—the identity and five elements of order 22.

What the groups have in common

The groups are different, but several structural facts coincide. Both have center of order 22: Z(Q8)={1,−1}Z(Q_8)=\{1,-1\} and Z(D8)={1,r2}Z(D_8)=\{1,r^2\}. In each case, quotienting by the center gives the Klein four-group V4V_4.

They do not have the same number of elements of order 44: Q8Q_8 has six, while D8D_8 has two. What they share is that each has a cyclic subgroup of order 44. Similarities such as equal group order, center size, or quotient structure do not establish that two groups are isomorphic.

Common mistakes

  • Assuming equal order means isomorphic. There are several nonisomorphic groups of order 88; order alone does not determine a group.
  • Counting the identity as order 22. The identity has order 11. It is included when counting solutions to x2=1x^2=1, but must be excluded when counting elements of order exactly 22.
  • Assuming every reflection has a corresponding quaternion element. The groups do not have matching element-order patterns: reflections have order 22, while the six noncentral elements of Q8Q_8 have order 44.
  • Reading D8D_8 without checking the convention. Some authors write D8D_8 for a dihedral group of order 1616. The presentation or stated group order resolves the ambiguity.

References

  1. Abstract Algebra, David S. Dummit and Richard M. Foote
  2. A First Course in Abstract Algebra, John B. Fraleigh

Spotted an error? Send a correction. Read how we write and check articles in our editorial policy.