Ma · Mathematics

What Is a Non-Normal Subgroup of S₃?

Published By the 9to5Science editorial team

At a glance

  1. 1. Choose a transposition

    Take H = {e, (12)}, the subgroup generated by the transposition (12).

  2. 2. Conjugate an element

    Conjugate (12) by (123); the result is the different transposition (23).

  3. 3. Compare the subgroups

    Since (23) is not in H, conjugation does not preserve H, so H is not normal.

Advertisement

A standard example is the two-element subgroup generated by a transposition. In cycle notation, take H={e,(12)}H=\{e,(12)\} inside the symmetric group S3S_3. It is a subgroup, but it is not normal: conjugating one of its elements by an element of S3S_3 produces an element outside HH.

The subgroup and the normality test

The group S3S_3 consists of all permutations of three objects:

S3={e,(12),(13),(23),(123),(132)}.S_3=\{e,(12),(13),(23),(123),(132)\}.

Here ee is the identity, the three two-cycles are transpositions, and the two three-cycles rotate all three objects. The set H={e,(12)}H=\{e,(12)\} is a subgroup because it contains the identity and is closed under products and inverses: (12)2=e(12)^2=e, and (12)−1=(12)(12)^{-1}=(12).

A subgroup HH of a group GG is normal if conjugating any element of HH by any element of GG keeps the result in HH. Equivalently, gHg−1=HgHg^{-1}=H for every g∈Gg\in G. To show that a subgroup is not normal, it is enough to find one g∈Gg\in G and one h∈Hh\in H for which ghg−1∉Hghg^{-1}\notin H.

Check a conjugate directly

Choose g=(123)g=(123) and h=(12)h=(12). Under the usual permutation-composition convention, conjugation relabels the entries in a cycle: g(a b)g−1=(g(a) g(b))g(a\ b)g^{-1}=(g(a)\ g(b)). Since g(1)=2g(1)=2 and g(2)=3g(2)=3,

(123)(12)(123)−1=(23).(123)(12)(123)^{-1}=(23).

But (23)∉H(23)\notin H, whose only elements are ee and (12)(12). Therefore gHg−1={e,(23)}≠HgHg^{-1}=\{e,(23)\}\ne H, and HH is not normal in S3S_3.

The same conclusion follows from the conjugation criterion in element form: normality would require ghg−1∈Hghg^{-1}\in H for every g∈S3g\in S_3 and h∈Hh\in H. This single calculation violates that requirement.

Why this example is typical

In fact, each subgroup of S3S_3 generated by a transposition is not normal. Conjugation can send one transposition to another, and the resulting two-element subgroup is different. For example, the subgroups {e,(12)}\{e,(12)\} and {e,(23)}\{e,(23)\} are distinct.

By contrast, the subgroup A3={e,(123),(132)}A_3=\{e,(123),(132)\} is normal in S3S_3. Conjugating a three-cycle by any permutation gives a three-cycle, so its conjugates stay in A3A_3. This provides a useful contrast: S3S_3 has both normal and non-normal subgroups.

Common mistakes

  • Checking only closure: Showing that HH is a subgroup does not show it is normal. Normality requires an additional conjugation test.
  • Checking only one conjugating element: A subgroup is normal only if the condition holds for every element of the larger group. To disprove normality, however, one counterexample is enough.
  • Confusing conjugation with multiplication: The relevant expression is ghg−1ghg^{-1}, not merely ghgh. The inverse on the right is part of the normality test.
  • Assuming every subgroup of S3S_3 is normal: The transposition subgroup above is a counterexample.

References

  1. Abstract Algebra, David S. Dummit and Richard M. Foote

Spotted an error? Send a correction. Read how we write and check articles in our editorial policy.