Ma · Mathematics

Why Is the Supremum of {x ∈ ℝ : x² < 7} Equal to √7?

Published By the 9to5Science editorial team

At a glance

  1. 1. Rewrite the condition

    Since x² < 7 is equivalent to |x| < √7, the set is the open interval (−√7, √7).

  2. 2. Check an upper bound

    Every element of the set is less than √7, so √7 is an upper bound.

  3. 3. Show it is least

    For every ε > 0, find an element of the set greater than √7 − ε.

The condition x2<7x^2<7 describes all real numbers whose distance from 00 is less than 7\sqrt{7}. The set therefore has points up to, but not including, 7\sqrt{7}. To prove that 7\sqrt{7} is its supremum, you need to show both that it is an upper bound and that no smaller number is an upper bound.

Rewrite the set as an interval

Because 7>07>0, the inequality x2<7x^2<7 is equivalent to ∣x∣<7|x|<\sqrt{7}. In turn, this means −7<x<7-\sqrt{7}<x<\sqrt{7}. Hence

X=(−7,7).X=(-\sqrt{7},\sqrt{7}).

The endpoints are not included: substituting either 7\sqrt{7} or −7-\sqrt{7} gives x2=7x^2=7, not x2<7x^2<7.

Prove that 7\sqrt{7} is the supremum

A number uu is an upper bound for XX if every x∈Xx\in X satisfies x≤ux\leq u. The supremum is the least such upper bound.

First, 7\sqrt{7} is an upper bound. If x∈Xx\in X, then x<7x<\sqrt{7}, so in particular x≤7x\leq\sqrt{7}. Thus 7\sqrt{7} is an upper bound.

Second, no smaller number is an upper bound. Take any u<7u<\sqrt{7}, and let ε=7−u>0\varepsilon=\sqrt{7}-u>0. By the Archimedean property of the real numbers, there is a positive integer nn large enough that 1/n<ε1/n<\varepsilon. Set

x=7−1n.x=\sqrt{7}-\frac{1}{n}.

This number is less than 7\sqrt{7}. Choose nn large enough also that 1/n<71/n<\sqrt{7}; then x>0x>0, so x2<7x^2<7 and x∈Xx\in X. And because 1/n<ε1/n<\varepsilon,

x=7−1n>7−ε=u.x=\sqrt{7}-\frac{1}{n}>\sqrt{7}-\varepsilon=u.

So uu cannot be an upper bound. Since this works for every u<7u<\sqrt{7}, no number smaller than 7\sqrt{7} is an upper bound. These two facts prove

sup⁡X=7.\sup X=\sqrt{7}.

A concrete approximation

For example, take ε=0.01\varepsilon=0.01. The number

x=7−0.005≈2.64075x=\sqrt{7}-0.005\approx 2.64075

lies in XX: it is positive and smaller than 7\sqrt{7}, so its square is less than 77. It is also greater than 7−0.01\sqrt{7}-0.01. This illustrates how elements of XX can be found within any chosen positive distance of 7\sqrt{7} from below. The proof works for every ε>0\varepsilon>0, not just 0.010.01.

Supremum is not the same as maximum

The maximum of a set must be an element of that set. The supremum need not be. Here, 7\sqrt{7} is the supremum, but it is not in XX because (7)2=7(\sqrt{7})^2=7 does not satisfy the strict inequality. Consequently, XX has no maximum.

This distinction is why it would be incorrect to say that 7\sqrt{7} is the largest element of XX. There is no largest element: if x∈Xx\in X, then x<7x<\sqrt{7}, and there is always another element of XX between xx and 7\sqrt{7}.

Common mistakes

  • Including the endpoint: The strict inequality excludes both endpoints. The interval is open, not closed.
  • Checking only that 7\sqrt{7} is an upper bound: That alone does not prove it is the least upper bound. You must also rule out every smaller upper bound.
  • Calling the supremum a maximum: A supremum can lie outside the set. In this example it does.
  • Ignoring negative values: The full set includes numbers from −7-\sqrt{7} up to 7\sqrt{7}. The negative endpoint does not affect the supremum, which concerns the upper end of the set.

References

  1. Understanding Analysis — Stephen Abbott

Spotted an error? Send a correction. Read how we write and check articles in our editorial policy.