Why Is the Supremum of {x ∈ ℝ : x² < 7} Equal to √7?
At a glance
- 1. Rewrite the condition
Since x² < 7 is equivalent to |x| < √7, the set is the open interval (−√7, √7).
- 2. Check an upper bound
Every element of the set is less than √7, so √7 is an upper bound.
- 3. Show it is least
For every ε > 0, find an element of the set greater than √7 − ε.
The condition describes all real numbers whose distance from is less than . The set therefore has points up to, but not including, . To prove that is its supremum, you need to show both that it is an upper bound and that no smaller number is an upper bound.
Rewrite the set as an interval
Because , the inequality is equivalent to . In turn, this means . Hence
The endpoints are not included: substituting either or gives , not .
Prove that is the supremum
A number is an upper bound for if every satisfies . The supremum is the least such upper bound.
First, is an upper bound. If , then , so in particular . Thus is an upper bound.
Second, no smaller number is an upper bound. Take any , and let . By the Archimedean property of the real numbers, there is a positive integer large enough that . Set
This number is less than . Choose large enough also that ; then , so and . And because ,
So cannot be an upper bound. Since this works for every , no number smaller than is an upper bound. These two facts prove
A concrete approximation
For example, take . The number
lies in : it is positive and smaller than , so its square is less than . It is also greater than . This illustrates how elements of can be found within any chosen positive distance of from below. The proof works for every , not just .
Supremum is not the same as maximum
The maximum of a set must be an element of that set. The supremum need not be. Here, is the supremum, but it is not in because does not satisfy the strict inequality. Consequently, has no maximum.
This distinction is why it would be incorrect to say that is the largest element of . There is no largest element: if , then , and there is always another element of between and .
Common mistakes
- Including the endpoint: The strict inequality excludes both endpoints. The interval is open, not closed.
- Checking only that is an upper bound: That alone does not prove it is the least upper bound. You must also rule out every smaller upper bound.
- Calling the supremum a maximum: A supremum can lie outside the set. In this example it does.
- Ignoring negative values: The full set includes numbers from up to . The negative endpoint does not affect the supremum, which concerns the upper end of the set.
References
- Understanding Analysis — Stephen Abbott
Spotted an error? Send a correction. Read how we write and check articles in our editorial policy.