Ma · Mathematics

Infimum and Supremum of Rational Numbers with x² < 2

Published By the 9to5Science editorial team

At a glance

  1. 1. Identify the set

    Take the set to be all rational numbers x such that x² < 2, with bounds considered in the real numbers.

  2. 2. Find the bounds

    The inequality implies −√2 < x < √2, so −√2 is a lower bound and √2 is an upper bound.

  3. 3. Show they are sharp

    Rational numbers lie arbitrarily close to √2 from below, and by symmetry arbitrarily close to −√2 from above.

  4. 4. Check attainment

    Neither endpoint is rational, so the set has no minimum or maximum.

Assume the set meant is

A={x∈Q:x2<2},A=\{x\in\mathbb{Q}:x^2<2\},

and that its infimum and supremum are being taken in R\mathbb{R}. The set contains only rational numbers, but its least upper bound and greatest lower bound need not be rational. In this case, they are 2\sqrt{2} and −2-\sqrt{2}.

Why these numbers are bounds

If x2<2x^2<2, then ∣x∣<2|x|<\sqrt{2}. Equivalently,

−2<x<2.-\sqrt{2}<x<\sqrt{2}.

Therefore every member of AA is at most 2\sqrt{2} and at least −2-\sqrt{2}. So 2\sqrt{2} is an upper bound and −2-\sqrt{2} is a lower bound.

Being a bound is not enough to establish a supremum or infimum: you must also show that no closer bound works. The key fact is that the rational numbers are dense in the real numbers. Between any two distinct real numbers there is a rational number.

Why the bounds are least and greatest

Take any ε>0\varepsilon>0. Density gives a rational number qq in the interval

(max⁡{0,2−ε},2).\bigl(\max\{0,\sqrt{2}-\varepsilon\},\sqrt{2}\bigr).

This interval is nonempty, and its rational qq satisfies 0<q<20<q<\sqrt{2}. Hence q2<2q^2<2, so q∈Aq\in A. Also, q>2−εq>\sqrt{2}-\varepsilon. Thus members of AA can be found arbitrarily close to 2\sqrt{2} from below. No number smaller than 2\sqrt{2} can be an upper bound, so

sup⁡A=2.\sup A=\sqrt{2}.

The set is symmetric: if q∈Aq\in A, then −q∈A-q\in A as well, since (−q)2=q2(-q)^2=q^2. Negating rational numbers that approach 2\sqrt{2} from below gives members approaching −2-\sqrt{2} from above. Therefore

inf⁡A=−2.\inf A=-\sqrt{2}.

A concrete approximation

For example, 1.41=141/1001.41=141/100 is rational and

1.412=1.9881<2.1.41^2=1.9881<2.

So 1.41∈A1.41\in A, and it is close to 2≈1.41421\sqrt{2}\approx1.41421. The number −1.41-1.41 is also in AA, close to −2-\sqrt{2}. More generally, density guarantees a member within any prescribed positive distance of either endpoint. The decimal example illustrates the idea; the density argument proves it for every ε>0\varepsilon>0.

Infimum is not minimum

An infimum does not have to be a member of the set. Here 2\sqrt{2} and −2-\sqrt{2} are irrational, while every member of AA is rational. Therefore neither endpoint belongs to AA:

  • AA has no maximum, even though its supremum is 2\sqrt{2}.
  • AA has no minimum, even though its infimum is −2-\sqrt{2}.

If the bounds were required to lie in Q\mathbb{Q} rather than R\mathbb{R}, this set would have no supremum or infimum in Q\mathbb{Q}. That is because the corresponding real values, 2\sqrt{2} and −2-\sqrt{2}, are not rational. Supremum and infimum questions should therefore specify, or make clear, the number system in which bounds are taken.

Common mistakes

  • Treating the endpoints as members: The inequality is strict, and in any case ±2\pm\sqrt{2} are irrational. They are not a maximum or minimum.
  • Assuming a rational set must have rational bounds: A subset of Q\mathbb{Q} can have an irrational supremum or infimum when considered as a subset of R\mathbb{R}.
  • Showing only that ±2\pm\sqrt{2} are bounds: To identify the supremum and infimum, also show that elements of the set come arbitrarily close to them. Density of Q\mathbb{Q} supplies that step.

If the intended condition was x2≤2x^2\le 2 instead, the answer is unchanged: equality would require x=±2x=\pm\sqrt{2}, and neither is rational, so the set of rational solutions is exactly the same.

Spotted an error? Send a correction. Read how we write and check articles in our editorial policy.