Ph · Physics

How Large Are the Extra Dimensions in String Theory?

Published By the 9to5Science editorial team

At a glance

  1. 1. Separate the scales

    The size of a compact dimension is not automatically the Planck length or the string length.

  2. 2. Specify the geometry

    A radius describes a simple circle; more complicated compact spaces can have several different characteristic sizes.

  3. 3. Use observable effects

    Compact dimensions can produce heavier copies of particles and changes to gravity at short distances.

  4. 4. Apply experimental limits

    Experiments constrain particular models, but do not give one universal size for string-theory dimensions.

Advertisement

String theory’s extra dimensions do not have one known, universal size. Their sizes are parameters of the chosen compactification: the mathematical geometry used to make the additional spatial dimensions consistent with the four large spacetime dimensions we observe. Some models assume dimensions near the string length, while others allow them to be much larger.

The important distinction is between a theory’s possible size scale and a size measured or predicted for a particular model. String theory by itself does not supply a single radius that applies to every solution.

What does “size” mean?

A common introductory picture is an extra dimension curled into a circle of radius RR. A traveler moving around that circle returns to the starting point after a distance 2πR2\pi R. In this simple case, RR is a clear measure of size.

Actual compactifications can be far more complicated than circles. String models often use a six-dimensional compact space; its directions need not have equal radii, and its shape may not be flat. It may therefore have several characteristic length scales rather than one. In a ten-dimensional superstring model, for example, six spatial dimensions are commonly compactified, leaving three large spatial dimensions and time. Other frameworks, such as M-theory, have a different number of dimensions.

The compactification geometry can also change over time or be affected by fields called moduli. A model needs a mechanism to fix those fields if its sizes are to remain stable.

Why does the radius matter physically?

If a dimension is compact, motion through it can appear to a four-dimensional observer as a set of additional particle states. For a circle of radius RR, the energy scale of the first such Kaluza–Klein excitation is approximately

E1∼ℏcR.E_1 \sim \frac{\hbar c}{R}.

The exact spectrum depends on the geometry and conventions, but the inverse relationship is the key point: a smaller radius means heavier excitations, which are harder to produce or detect.

Compact dimensions can also alter how gravity behaves at short distances. At distances much larger than their radii, gravity can look four-dimensional. At distances comparable to or smaller than the compactification scale, gravity may spread into the extra dimensions and follow a different distance law. This is one reason laboratory tests of gravity can constrain some models.

A worked scale comparison

Suppose one extra dimension were a circle with radius R=10−18R=10^{-18} metres. Using ℏc≈1.97×10−7\hbar c \approx 1.97\times10^{-7} electronvolt-metres gives

E1∼1.97×10−7 eV m10−18 m≈2.0×1011 eV≈200 GeV.E_1 \sim \frac{1.97\times10^{-7}\ \text{eV m}}{10^{-18}\ \text{m}} \approx 2.0\times10^{11}\ \text{eV} \approx 200\ \text{GeV}.

That is a high-energy particle scale, so a collider might in principle be sensitive to related effects, depending on how the extra dimension couples to known particles. If instead R=1R=1 micrometre, the corresponding scale is about 0.20.2 eV. These numbers illustrate the radius–energy relationship; they do not show that either radius is realized in nature.

What do experiments say?

Experiments test consequences, not the abstract radius in isolation. Searches for Kaluza–Klein states at colliders, precision measurements of gravity at short distances, and astrophysical observations each constrain different combinations of size, geometry, and coupling strengths.

In models with large, flat extra dimensions, the gravitational force could depart from the familiar inverse-square law at distances near the compactification scale. Laboratory measurements test gravity at submillimetre distances, including scales around tens of micrometres. Such results restrict particular large-extra-dimension models; they should not be read as a universal upper bound on every compact dimension in string theory. The limits depend on the number of dimensions, their shape, and how gravity and other fields propagate through them.

A familiar proposal relates the observed weakness of four-dimensional gravity to a larger fundamental gravity scale in a higher-dimensional space. In that setting, extra dimensions can be far larger than the Planck length. Other compactifications keep them close to the string scale. Both are model-building possibilities, not a settled measurement of their actual size.

Common mistakes

  • Equating the extra-dimension radius with the Planck length. The Planck length is a useful gravity scale, but it is not automatically the radius of a compact dimension. The string scale and compactification radii are also distinct quantities.
  • Assuming all extra dimensions have the same size. A compact space can be anisotropic, with some directions much larger than others.
  • Treating a proposed scenario as a string-theory prediction. A particular compactification may yield definite scales, but the broad framework admits many possibilities.
  • Interpreting “unseen” as “smaller than one fixed number.” A dimension can evade detection because its excitations are too heavy, its effects are too weak, or the relevant experiment does not probe the right phenomenon.

To get a meaningful size estimate, specify the compactification geometry and the physical effects being tested. Without those choices, the accurate answer is that string theory does not currently provide one experimentally established size for its extra dimensions.

References

  1. String Theory, Volume II: Superstring Theory — Joseph Polchinski
  2. The Hierarchy Problem and New Dimensions at a Millimeter — Nima Arkani-Hamed, Savas Dimopoulos, and Gia Dvali

Spotted an error? Send a correction. Read how we write and check articles in our editorial policy.