Ma · Mathematics

Can the Tensor Product of Two Irreducible Representations Be Reducible?

Published By the 9to5Science editorial team

At a glance

  1. 1. Set the context

    For a group acting diagonally on a tensor product, irreducibility of each factor does not guarantee irreducibility of the product.

  2. 2. Choose an example

    Take the two-dimensional standard irreducible representation of the symmetric group S3 over the complex numbers.

  3. 3. Compute the character

    The tensor-square character is the pointwise square of the standard character: its values are 4, 0, and 1.

  4. 4. Decompose the result

    Those values equal the sum of the trivial, sign, and standard characters, so the tensor square is reducible.

The tensor product of two irreducible representations is not necessarily irreducible. The answer depends on the group and on the representations: some tensor products split into smaller invariant subspaces, while others remain irreducible. Here is a standard finite-group example, worked out using characters.

The group action on a tensor product

If a group GG acts on representations VV and WW, its usual action on V⊗WV\otimes W is the diagonal action

g(v⊗w)=(gv)⊗(gw).g(v\otimes w)=(gv)\otimes(gw).

Even when neither factor has a nonzero proper invariant subspace, the tensor product can have one. Irreducibility of the factors alone does not rule out such subspaces.

We work over C\mathbb{C} and use G=S3G=S_3, the group of permutations of three objects. This setting is semisimple: every finite-dimensional representation of a finite group over C\mathbb{C} decomposes as a direct sum of irreducibles.

A concrete example: the standard representation of S3S_3

Let S3S_3 act on C3\mathbb{C}^3 by permuting coordinates. The one-dimensional subspace spanned by (1,1,1)(1,1,1) is fixed by every permutation. Its invariant complement

V={(x1,x2,x3)∈C3:x1+x2+x3=0}V=\{(x_1,x_2,x_3)\in\mathbb{C}^3:x_1+x_2+x_3=0\}

has dimension two and is the standard representation. It is irreducible over C\mathbb{C}.

The conjugacy classes of S3S_3 are the identity, the three transpositions, and the two 3-cycles. The character χV\chi_V of VV takes the values 2,0,−12,0,-1 on these classes, respectively. For example, the trace of a permutation on C3\mathbb{C}^3 is its number of fixed coordinates; subtracting the trace 11 of the fixed line gives the standard-character values.

Compute the tensor-square character

For representations with characters χV\chi_V and χW\chi_W, the character of the tensor product is their pointwise product:

χV⊗W(g)=χV(g)χW(g).\chi_{V\otimes W}(g)=\chi_V(g)\chi_W(g).

Thus the character of V⊗VV\otimes V has values

χV⊗V=(22,02,(−1)2)=(4,0,1),\chi_{V\otimes V}=(2^2,0^2,(-1)^2)=(4,0,1),

listed in the same class order: identity, transpositions, and 3-cycles.

The irreducible characters of S3S_3 are the trivial character χtriv=(1,1,1)\chi_{\mathrm{triv}}=(1,1,1), the sign character χsgn=(1,−1,1)\chi_{\mathrm{sgn}}=(1,-1,1), and the standard character χV=(2,0,−1)\chi_V=(2,0,-1). Adding them gives

χtriv+χsgn+χV=(4,0,1)=χV⊗V.\chi_{\mathrm{triv}}+\chi_{\mathrm{sgn}}+\chi_V=(4,0,1)=\chi_{V\otimes V}.

Characters determine complex representations of finite groups up to isomorphism, so this identity proves the decomposition

V⊗V≅1⊕sgn⊕V.V\otimes V\cong \mathbf{1}\oplus\mathrm{sgn}\oplus V.

The dimensions add up: 1+1+2=4=dim⁡(V⊗V)1+1+2=4=\dim(V\otimes V). Since the tensor square contains proper nonzero invariant summands, it is reducible, even though both factors are irreducible.

Why character addition detects the decomposition

A representation that is a direct sum has a character equal to the sum of the characters of its summands. Conversely, over C\mathbb{C} for a finite group, representations split into irreducibles, and the multiplicity of an irreducible character ψ\psi in a character χ\chi is the character inner product

⟨χ,ψ⟩=1∣G∣∑g∈Gχ(g)ψ(g)‾.\langle\chi,\psi\rangle=\frac{1}{|G|}\sum_{g\in G}\chi(g)\overline{\psi(g)}.

For S3S_3, this sum can be grouped by conjugacy classes, weighted by their sizes 1,3,21,3,2. Applying it to (4,0,1)(4,0,1) gives multiplicity 11 for each of the trivial, sign, and standard representations. The character sum above is the shorter equivalent check.

Common mistakes

  • Treating reducibility as automatic. The example disproves the claim that tensor products always preserve irreducibility; it does not show that every tensor product is reducible. For instance, any two one-dimensional representations have a one-dimensional, hence irreducible, tensor product.
  • Using the wrong group action. The representation on V⊗WV\otimes W here is the diagonal action, not the action of two independent group elements on the two factors.
  • Squaring dimensions instead of characters. The tensor-square dimension is 22=42^2=4, but that alone cannot identify its summands. The character values and their decomposition establish reducibility.
  • Ignoring the field. The example is stated over C\mathbb{C}. Over fields of positive characteristic, complete reducibility can fail when the characteristic divides the group order, so decomposition claims require additional care.

The practical test for finite groups over C\mathbb{C} is to compute the tensor-product character and decompose it into irreducible characters. The result can vary with the group and the chosen pair of irreducible representations.

References

  1. Jean-Pierre Serre, Linear Representations of Finite Groups
  2. William Fulton and Joe Harris, Representation Theory: A First Course

Spotted an error? Send a correction. Read how we write and check articles in our editorial policy.