Ph · Physics

What Does an Atom Radiate: a Wave Packet or a Single Photon?

Published By the 9to5Science editorial team

At a glance

  1. 1. Separate the ideas

    A photon is a quantum of the electromagnetic field; a wave packet describes how its quantum state is distributed across modes.

  2. 2. Follow the emission

    An ideal excited atom can decay into its lower state while the field gains one photon.

  3. 3. Read the packet

    The photon’s temporal and frequency distributions are set by the transition and the atom’s lifetime.

  4. 4. Interpret detection

    A detector records a localized event, even though the photon state can extend over space and time.

Advertisement

An atom does not have to choose between radiating a wave packet and emitting a photon. In quantum theory, these describe different aspects of the same process: a photon is the quantum of the electromagnetic field, while a wave packet describes the photon’s state across space, time, frequency, and direction.

For an ideal spontaneous transition from an excited atomic state to a lower one, the atom typically ends up in the lower state and the field contains one photon. That photon need not be a single-frequency plane wave. It is generally a superposition of field modes, which forms a wave packet.

What “one photon” means

A photon is not a tiny classical ball with a sharply defined path and size. In quantum electrodynamics, the field has modes—distinguished by properties such as frequency, direction, and polarization—and a one-photon state can be a superposition of those modes. The probability of detecting the photon at a particular place and time is determined by that state.

A simplified description of an atom coupled to the field starts with an excited atom and no photons, written ∣e,0⟩|e,0\rangle. During emission, the combined atom-and-field state can be expressed schematically as

∣Ψ(t)⟩=ce(t)∣e,0⟩+∑λ∫d3k ck,λ(t)∣g,1k,λ⟩.|\Psi(t)\rangle = c_e(t)|e,0\rangle + \sum_{\lambda}\int d^3k\,c_{\mathbf{k},\lambda}(t)|g,1_{\mathbf{k},\lambda}\rangle.

Here ∣g⟩|g\rangle is the lower atomic state, and ∣1k,λ⟩|1_{\mathbf{k},\lambda}\rangle denotes one photon in a mode with wave vector k\mathbf{k} and polarization λ\lambda. The coefficients describe the amplitudes of the possible field modes. Once the decay is complete in the idealized case, the atom is in ∣g⟩|g\rangle and the field is in a one-photon state made from a spread of modes.

Why the photon has a wave packet

A real atom emits over a finite time, not in an infinitely brief instant. A finite emission time implies a spread of frequencies. For a simple two-level atom with decay rate Γ\Gamma, the excited-state probability decays approximately as e−Γte^{-\Gamma t}, and the emitted field’s temporal amplitude has an envelope proportional to e−Γt/2e^{-\Gamma t/2} for t≥0t\geq 0.

In the usual idealized free-space model, the photon’s frequency distribution near the transition frequency ω0\omega_0 is approximately Lorentzian:

S(ω)∝1(ω−ω0)2+(Γ/2)2.S(\omega)\propto \frac{1}{(\omega-\omega_0)^2+(\Gamma/2)^2}.

The Lorentzian’s full width at half maximum is Γ\Gamma when frequency is measured in radians per second. If the excited-state lifetime is τ=1/Γ\tau=1/\Gamma, the corresponding linewidth in cycles per second is

Δν=Γ2π=12πτ.\Delta\nu=\frac{\Gamma}{2\pi}=\frac{1}{2\pi\tau}.

These expressions are an approximation for a simple isolated transition. The atom’s environment, external fields, motion, and the way it is excited can change the emitted packet’s shape and spectrum.

Worked example: a one-nanosecond lifetime

Suppose an excited state has lifetime τ=1 ns=10−9 s\tau=1\ \text{ns}=10^{-9}\ \text{s}. Its natural linewidth is approximately

Δν=12π(10−9 s)≈1.59×108 Hz=159 MHz.\Delta\nu=\frac{1}{2\pi(10^{-9}\ \text{s})}\approx 1.59\times 10^8\ \text{Hz}=159\ \text{MHz}.

The emission’s intensity envelope decays on a timescale of about one nanosecond. In free space, light travels roughly cτ≈0.30 mc\tau\approx 0.30\ \text{m} in that time, so the packet’s characteristic length along its direction of travel is on the order of tens of centimetres. This is an estimate, not a hard boundary: an exponential packet has tails, and the detailed spatial state depends on the emission geometry.

The atom has still emitted one photon. The packet’s length does not mean it is divided into many lower-energy photons. Nor does it imply that the photon’s energy is exactly hν0h\nu_0 in every idealized description: a finite linewidth corresponds to a small spread of frequencies and energies around the transition.

What a detector observes

A detector typically absorbs the photon in one localized event. The detection time and location are probabilistic, with probabilities determined by the photon state and the detector. This does not mean the photon was a classical wave that suddenly turned into a particle; it means a quantum state distributed across possible detection outcomes produced one registered absorption.

The emitted photon’s angular and polarization pattern also matters. A dipole transition, for example, does not radiate equally in every direction. In a cavity or waveguide, the available field modes can be quite different from those in free space, changing the emission rate and the packet. If the atom is driven again or undergoes a cascade through several levels, it can emit more than one photon; “one photon” describes a particular transition or decay channel, not every possible history of an atom.

Common mistakes

  • Treating “photon” and “wave packet” as alternatives. One names the quantum of the field; the other describes a state of that field.
  • Assuming a photon must have one exact frequency. A finite-duration emission generally has a frequency distribution. An ideal monochromatic mode would extend indefinitely in time.
  • Picturing a packet as a rigid little blob. Its shape is a probability-amplitude distribution, not a sharply bounded object with a classical surface.
  • Confusing a detection event with the whole photon state. A localized click is one outcome of a measurement; it does not by itself specify the state’s full spatial or temporal extent.

So, for a simple spontaneous decay, the most useful description is: the atom emits one photon in a wave-packet state. The photon’s packet is shaped by the atomic transition and by its electromagnetic surroundings.

References

  1. Atom-Photon Interactions: Basic Processes and Applications — Claude Cohen-Tannoudji, Jacques Dupont-Roc, and Gilbert Grynberg
  2. The Quantum Theory of Light — Rodney Loudon

Spotted an error? Send a correction. Read how we write and check articles in our editorial policy.