Ma · Mathematics

How to Find the Water Depth Rate in a Conical Tank

Published By the 9to5Science editorial team

At a glance

  1. 1. Relate radius and depth

    Use similar triangles to express the water-surface radius in terms of the water depth.

  2. 2. Write the volume

    Substitute that radius into the cone volume formula to get volume as a function of depth.

  3. 3. Differentiate in time

    Differentiate the volume equation implicitly, keeping the volume and depth rates.

  4. 4. Substitute values

    Insert the instantaneous depth and net filling rate, then solve for the depth rate.

Advertisement

To find how quickly water depth changes in a conical tank, first connect the water’s volume to its depth. The radius of the water’s surface changes as the tank fills, so it cannot be treated as a constant. Similar triangles provide the needed relationship.

For a tank with full height HH and top radius RR, if the water depth is hh and its surface radius is rr, then

rh=RH.\frac{r}{h}=\frac{R}{H}.

After substituting this into the cone-volume formula, differentiate with respect to time. The result gives the depth rate from the net volume rate and the current depth.

Derive the depth-rate formula

The volume of a cone is

V=13πr2h.V=\frac{1}{3}\pi r^2h.

Because the water forms a smaller cone similar to the tank, r/h=R/Hr/h=R/H, so r=(R/H)hr=(R/H)h. Substitute that expression into the volume formula:

V=13π(RHh)2h=πR23H2h3.\begin{aligned} V&=\frac{1}{3}\pi\left(\frac{R}{H}h\right)^2h\\ &=\frac{\pi R^2}{3H^2}h^3. \end{aligned}

Differentiate both sides with respect to time tt. The dimensions RR and HH are fixed, but VV and hh change with time:

dVdt=πR2H2h2dhdt.\frac{dV}{dt}=\frac{\pi R^2}{H^2}h^2\frac{dh}{dt}.

Solving for the rate of change of the water depth gives

dhdt=H2πR2h2dVdt.\boxed{\frac{dh}{dt}=\frac{H^2}{\pi R^2h^2}\frac{dV}{dt}}.

Here, dV/dtdV/dt is the net rate of volume change. If water flows in at rate QinQ_{\text{in}} and drains at rate QoutQ_{\text{out}}, then dV/dt=Qin−QoutdV/dt=Q_{\text{in}}-Q_{\text{out}}. The sign of dh/dtdh/dt follows the sign of this net rate.

Worked example

Suppose a conical tank is 12 m high and has a top radius of 4 m. Water flows in at a steady rate of 2 m3/min2\text{ m}^3/\text{min}. Find how fast the water depth is increasing when the water is 3 m deep.

Use H=12H=12, R=4R=4, h=3h=3, and dV/dt=2dV/dt=2 in the formula:

dhdt=122π(42)(32)(2)=288144π=2π m/min≈0.637 m/min.\begin{aligned} \frac{dh}{dt} &=\frac{12^2}{\pi(4^2)(3^2)}(2)\\ &=\frac{288}{144\pi}\\ &=\frac{2}{\pi}\text{ m/min}\\ &\approx 0.637\text{ m/min}. \end{aligned}

At that instant, the water depth is rising at about 0.637 m/min0.637\text{ m/min}. This is an instantaneous rate, not the average rate over the time required to fill the tank. As the water gets deeper, its surface radius grows, so the same volume inflow produces a smaller depth increase per minute.

A direct check using the water radius

At depth 3 m, similarity gives

r=RHh=412(3)=1 m.r=\frac{R}{H}h=\frac{4}{12}(3)=1\text{ m}.

Differentiating V=13πr2hV=\frac{1}{3}\pi r^2h directly would involve both rr and hh changing. Since r=h/3r=h/3, their rates satisfy dr/dt=(1/3)dh/dtdr/dt=(1/3)dh/dt. Substituting that relationship into the differentiated volume equation gives the same result. Using volume as a function of depth from the start is usually shorter and reduces the chance of losing a changing-radius term.

Common mistakes

  • Holding the water radius fixed. The radius changes with depth. Use r=(R/H)hr=(R/H)h before differentiating, or account for dr/dtdr/dt explicitly.
  • Using the tank’s dimensions as the water dimensions. RR and HH describe the entire tank; rr and hh describe the water at the instant in question.
  • Using the wrong sign. A draining tank has dV/dt<0dV/dt<0, so the calculated depth rate should also be negative.
  • Mixing units. If dimensions are in meters and volume rate is in liters per minute, convert liters to cubic meters before substituting: 10001000 L equals 1 m31\text{ m}^3.
  • Confusing radius with diameter. If the problem gives the top diameter, divide it by 2 to obtain RR.

The formula assumes an ideal cone and a uniform water level. It also applies only while the water occupies a cone similar to the tank—for example, in an upright tank with its tip at the bottom. At exactly h=0h=0, the formula is undefined; real filling behavior near the tip is affected by the tank’s geometry and other physical details.

Spotted an error? Send a correction. Read how we write and check articles in our editorial policy.