Ma · Mathematics

How to Find the Rate of Change of an Icicle’s Volume

Published By the 9to5Science editorial team

At a glance

  1. 1. Model the icicle

    Approximate it as a cone, with radius r and axial length h.

  2. 2. Write the volume

    Use the cone formula V = (1/3)πr²h.

  3. 3. Differentiate in time

    Apply the product rule, since both radius and length can change.

  4. 4. Substitute signed rates

    Insert the measurements and rates at the same instant; negative rates represent shrinking.

An icicle is often approximated as a cone. If its radius and axial length are both changing, its volume changes because of both changes—not just because its length or radius changes alone.

The formula below gives the volume rate at a particular instant. It assumes the icicle keeps a conical shape and that “length” means the distance from the tip to the circular base along the cone’s axis.

Start with the cone’s volume

Let rr be the radius of the circular base and hh the icicle’s axial length. The cone’s volume is

V=13πr2h.V=\frac{1}{3}\pi r^2h.

Because rr and hh can depend on time, differentiate both sides with respect to time. The product rule is needed for r2hr^2h:

dVdt=π3(2rhdrdt+r2dhdt).\frac{dV}{dt} =\frac{\pi}{3}\left(2rh\frac{dr}{dt}+r^2\frac{dh}{dt}\right).

This is the related-rates formula. The first term measures the contribution from the changing radius; the second measures the contribution from the changing length. Both rates must be evaluated at the same instant as rr and hh.

Work through an example

Suppose an icicle has radius 0.500.50 m and axial length 2.02.0 m at a particular moment. As it melts, its radius is shrinking at 0.0100.010 m/min and its length at 0.0300.030 m/min. Since both dimensions are decreasing, use negative signed rates:

r=0.50,h=2.0,drdt=−0.010,dhdt=−0.030.r=0.50,\qquad h=2.0,\qquad \frac{dr}{dt}=-0.010,\qquad \frac{dh}{dt}=-0.030.

Substitute into the formula:

dVdt=π3[2(0.50)(2.0)(−0.010)+(0.50)2(−0.030)]=π3(−0.020−0.0075)=−0.0091667π m3/min≈−0.0288 m3/min.\begin{aligned} \frac{dV}{dt} &=\frac{\pi}{3}\left[2(0.50)(2.0)(-0.010)+(0.50)^2(-0.030)\right] \\ &=\frac{\pi}{3}(-0.020-0.0075) \\ &=-0.0091667\pi\ \text{m}^3/\text{min} \\ &\approx -0.0288\ \text{m}^3/\text{min}. \end{aligned}

The negative result means the volume is decreasing. At that instant, it is decreasing at about 0.02880.0288 cubic metres per minute. The negative sign is part of the signed rate; it does not mean the icicle has a negative volume.

What if the given length is slant length?

The cone formula uses vertical height, not the distance along the sloping side. If the stated length ss is the slant length, use the right-triangle relation

h=s2−r2.h=\sqrt{s^2-r^2}.

For h>0h>0, differentiating this relation gives

dhdt=s ds/dt−r dr/dth.\frac{dh}{dt}=\frac{s\,ds/dt-r\,dr/dt}{h}.

Find hh and dh/dtdh/dt from the measured slant length and its rate, then use the cone related-rates formula. This avoids treating slant length as height, which generally gives the wrong volume rate.

Common mistakes

  • Leaving out one changing dimension. If both radius and length vary, both terms in the derivative are needed.
  • Forgetting the product rule. The volume contains r2hr^2h, a product of time-dependent quantities.
  • Using positive rates for shrinking dimensions. A rate of decrease should be entered as negative. Alternatively, calculate a positive decrease magnitude and state that the volume is decreasing, but do not mix the two conventions.
  • Confusing radius with diameter. If the measurement given is diameter dd, first use r=d/2r=d/2; its rate is dr/dt=(1/2)dd/dtdr/dt=(1/2)dd/dt.
  • Using the wrong length. The standard cone formula requires axial height. Convert a slant measurement before differentiating the volume.
  • Assuming every icicle is a perfect cone. The result is an estimate based on the cone model. Irregular icicles may need a more detailed geometric model or direct measurements.

References

  1. OpenStax, Calculus Volume 1

Spotted an error? Send a correction. Read how we write and check articles in our editorial policy.