Ph · Physics

What Is Maupertuis’ Principle Good For?

Published By the 9to5Science editorial team

At a glance

  1. 1. Fix the energy

    Choose a conserved energy and the two endpoint configurations.

  2. 2. Vary the path

    Find a stationary value of the abbreviated action, the integral of momentum along the path.

  3. 3. Recover the motion

    Use the energy relation to determine how quickly the system moves along the resulting path.

Advertisement

Maupertuis’ principle is a variational method for finding the shape of a trajectory at a fixed energy. It is especially useful when you care about which route a system takes through configuration space, rather than how long it takes to travel that route.

The principle’s value is both practical and conceptual: it can recast mechanics as a geometric problem and connects naturally to optics and Hamilton–Jacobi theory. To use it well, keep in mind that it does not, by itself, specify the time parametrization of the motion.

The abbreviated action

For a system with generalized coordinates qiq_i and conjugate momenta pip_i, Maupertuis’ principle says that the abbreviated action

W=∫qAqB∑ipi dqiW=\int_{q_A}^{q_B}\sum_i p_i\,dq_i

is stationary under suitable changes in the path between fixed endpoint configurations. The variations are made at fixed energy EE; the travel time is allowed to vary. “Stationary” means that the first-order change is zero. It does not necessarily mean the action is a minimum.

For an autonomous, conservative system with a regular Lagrangian, this stationary-path condition gives the same physical trajectory as the usual equations of motion, provided the motion is considered on the chosen energy surface. It determines the path in configuration space, not its timing.

That is the main distinction from Hamilton’s principle, which makes the time integral of the Lagrangian stationary for fixed endpoint positions and fixed endpoint times. Hamilton’s principle directly describes the time-dependent motion. Maupertuis’ principle instead focuses on the route taken at a specified energy.

Why a fixed-energy principle can be useful

For a natural mechanical system, write the kinetic energy as

T=12∑i,jgij(q)q˙iq˙j,T=\frac12\sum_{i,j}g_{ij}(q)\dot q_i\dot q_j,

where gijg_{ij} is the mass metric, and let the potential energy be V(q)V(q). The energy is E=T+VE=T+V. At a point on the trajectory, the energy condition gives T=E−V(q)T=E-V(q), so the abbreviated-action element can be written as

∑ipi dqi=2(E−V(q))∑i,jgij(q) dqi dqj.\sum_i p_i\,dq_i=\sqrt{2(E-V(q))\sum_{i,j}g_{ij}(q)\,dq_i\,dq_j}.

Thus, for fixed EE, finding the mechanical path is equivalent to finding a stationary-length curve in a geometry weighted by E−V(q)E-V(q). This is the Jacobi metric viewpoint. It is useful when geometric tools—such as geodesics, symmetries, or comparisons between paths—make the problem easier to understand or solve.

Once the path is known, recover elapsed time from the energy relation. If dsg2=∑i,jgij dqi dqjds_g^2=\sum_{i,j}g_{ij}\,dq_i\,dq_j, then

dt=dsg2(E−V(q)).dt=\frac{ds_g}{\sqrt{2(E-V(q))}}.

The path and its timing are therefore separate parts of the calculation: Maupertuis’ principle finds the former, and the energy equation supplies the latter.

Worked example: a particle in a gravitational field

Consider a particle of mass mm moving in a vertical plane, with coordinates (x,y)(x,y) and gravitational potential V(y)=mgyV(y)=mgy. Its kinetic energy is T=12m(x˙2+y˙2)T=\frac12m(\dot x^2+\dot y^2), and its conserved energy is E=T+mgyE=T+mgy.

For a curve in the plane, ds2=dx2+dy2ds^2=dx^2+dy^2. The abbreviated-action element along that curve is

px dx+py dy=mx˙ dx+my˙ dy=2m(E−mgy) dx2+dy2.\begin{aligned} p_x\,dx+p_y\,dy &=m\dot x\,dx+m\dot y\,dy\\ &=\sqrt{2m(E-mgy)}\,\sqrt{dx^2+dy^2}. \end{aligned}

Maupertuis’ principle says to make the integral of this quantity stationary between the chosen endpoints. The factor multiplying the ordinary distance depends on height: paths through regions with different potential energy are weighted differently. This gives a geometric way to characterize the trajectory without first solving for position as a function of time.

After finding the curve, use dt=ds/2(E−mgy)/mdt=ds/\sqrt{2(E-mgy)/m} to recover the time along it. The expression applies where E≥mgyE\ge mgy, since the kinetic energy cannot be negative. At a turning point, where E=mgyE=mgy, the time parametrization needs care even though the path description can remain meaningful.

Connections and applications

  • Optics: Fermat’s principle finds stationary optical path length. In suitable settings, its mathematical structure parallels the fixed-energy mechanical path principle, helping explain why rays and mechanical trajectories can be treated with related geometric methods.
  • Hamilton–Jacobi theory: The function W(q)W(q) obtained by integrating pi dqip_i\,dq_i is Hamilton’s characteristic function for a system at fixed energy. This connection can help when seeking separated solutions or using conserved quantities.
  • Orbit shapes: In conservative dynamics, fixing the energy lets you study the configuration-space route independently of the clock. This is useful in qualitative analysis and in geometric formulations of mechanics.

Common mistakes

  1. Calling it a principle of least action. The path is stationary, not necessarily the path with the smallest value of WW.
  2. Treating it as a formula for time. The integral ∫pi dqi\int p_i\,dq_i determines a path at fixed energy. Use the energy relation to recover timing.
  3. Confusing it with Hamilton’s principle. The two principles have different actions and boundary conditions. They produce equivalent dynamics under the appropriate assumptions, but are not the same variational statement.
  4. Applying it without conserved energy. The usual form assumes an autonomous conservative system. If energy changes with time, this fixed-energy formulation does not directly apply; a time-dependent variational formulation is more appropriate.
  5. Ignoring turning points or forbidden regions. For a natural system, the Jacobi expression requires E−V(q)≥0E-V(q)\ge0. Where E<V(q)E<V(q), the assumed real classical motion cannot pass; at E=V(q)E=V(q), the time-recovery formula becomes singular.

References

  1. Classical Mechanics, Herbert Goldstein, Charles Poole, and John Safko
  2. Mechanics, L. D. Landau and E. M. Lifshitz

Spotted an error? Send a correction. Read how we write and check articles in our editorial policy.