What Is Markovnikov’s Rule?
At a glance
- 1. Identify the alkene
Find the two carbons of the carbon–carbon double bond. If they are equivalent, there is no regioselectivity question.
- 2. Compare the carbons
For the usual addition of HX, hydrogen goes to the double-bond carbon that already has more hydrogen atoms.
- 3. Place the other group
The halogen or other incoming group usually bonds to the more substituted carbon.
- 4. Check the reaction
The rule is a useful prediction, not a universal law; mechanisms and conditions can change the outcome.
Markovnikov’s rule predicts which of two possible orientations is favored when a reagent adds across an unsymmetrical carbon–carbon double bond. It is most often introduced for adding a hydrogen halide, HX, such as HBr or HCl, to an alkene.
The quick prediction is: hydrogen attaches to the double-bond carbon that already has more hydrogen atoms, and the halogen attaches to the other, more substituted carbon. The reason is usually the relative stability of intermediates formed along the reaction pathway.
The rule for adding HX
Consider an alkene whose double-bond carbons are not equivalent. Adding HX breaks the carbon–carbon double bond and forms two new bonds: one between H and an alkene carbon, and one between X and the other carbon. Either orientation may be drawn, but one is often favored.
For the usual ionic addition, the alkene is first protonated. The proton can attach to either carbon, leaving a positively charged carbon (a carbocation) on the other. The favored orientation is generally the one that forms the more stable carbocation. A tertiary carbocation is usually more stable than a secondary one, which is usually more stable than a primary one.
The halide ion, X⁻, then bonds to the carbocation. Thus, in the common case, X ends up on the more substituted carbon, while H ends up on the carbon that had more hydrogen atoms. This is the usual Markovnikov product.
Worked example: propene and HBr
Propene has the structure CH₃–CH=CH₂. Its double-bond carbons are not equivalent: the middle carbon is attached to one hydrogen, while the terminal carbon is attached to two.
When HBr adds under ordinary ionic conditions, there are two possible orientations:
- If H bonds to the terminal CH₂ carbon, the positive charge is left on the middle carbon. This gives a secondary carbocation.
- If H bonds to the middle carbon, the positive charge is left on the terminal carbon. This gives a primary carbocation.
The secondary carbocation is more stable, so the first pathway is favored. Bromide then bonds to the middle carbon, giving CH₃–CHBr–CH₃, or 2-bromopropane, as the expected Markovnikov product.
In this example, the hydrogen goes to the alkene carbon that already had more hydrogen atoms (the terminal carbon), and bromine goes to the more substituted carbon (the middle carbon). This is a regioselectivity prediction: it tells you which constitutional isomer is favored, not necessarily how much of each product forms.
Applying the idea to other additions
The rule is also used to describe acid-catalyzed hydration of an unsymmetrical alkene. In the usual textbook case, water adds so that the OH group ends up on the more substituted alkene carbon and H ends up on the other one. For example, acid-catalyzed hydration of propene generally gives 2-propanol rather than 1-propanol.
Be careful to name the groups being added. The shorthand “hydrogen goes to the carbon with more hydrogens” is especially useful for HX addition, but for another reagent you should state which incoming group is predicted to attach to which carbon. The underlying question is the orientation of addition, also called regioselectivity.
Important exception: anti-Markovnikov addition
The same alkene can give the opposite orientation under different conditions. A standard example is the radical addition of HBr in the presence of peroxides. In that reaction, bromine attaches to the less substituted alkene carbon, and hydrogen attaches to the more substituted one. For propene, this gives 1-bromopropane rather than 2-bromopropane.
This peroxide effect is characteristic of HBr under suitable radical conditions. It should not be generalized to HCl or HI: their radical chain steps are not comparably favorable. Another common way to achieve anti-Markovnikov hydration is hydroboration–oxidation, which places OH on the less substituted carbon overall.
Common mistakes
- Treating the rule as universal. It predicts common outcomes, not every possible addition. Check the reagent and mechanism.
- Confusing “more substituted” with “more hydrogens.” For the usual HX rule, these descriptions point to opposite alkene carbons: H goes to the carbon with more hydrogens; X usually goes to the more substituted one.
- Assuming the rule tells you the amount of product. It predicts favored orientation. It does not, by itself, give a product ratio or reaction yield.
- Applying it when the alkene carbons are equivalent. If symmetry makes the two orientations identical, there is no distinct Markovnikov-versus-anti-Markovnikov choice.
- Ignoring reaction conditions. For example, ordinary ionic addition of HBr and peroxide-initiated radical addition can favor opposite products.
Markovnikov’s rule is therefore best used as a first prediction: identify the alkene’s two possible orientations, then consider the mechanism and conditions to determine which one is favored.
References
- Organic Chemistry, Jonathan Clayden, Nick Greeves, and Stuart Warren
- Organic Chemistry, T. W. Graham Solomons, Craig B. Fryhle, and Scott A. Snyder
Spotted an error? Send a correction. Read how we write and check articles in our editorial policy.