Ph · Physics

What Are Non-Local Hidden Variables?

Published By the 9to5Science editorial team

At a glance

  1. 1. Define hidden variables

    They are additional variables proposed to help determine or explain quantum measurement outcomes.

  2. 2. Check locality

    A local model lets each measurement depend on its own setting and the shared past, but not the distant setting.

  3. 3. Apply Bell's theorem

    Bell inequalities limit correlations any local hidden-variable model can produce.

  4. 4. Interpret violations

    Experiments violate those limits, so a hidden-variable account reproducing quantum predictions must give up Bell locality.

Advertisement

A hidden-variable theory adds variables to quantum mechanics in an attempt to account for measurement outcomes. The phrase non-local hidden variables usually means that the theory permits those variables—or the rules determining outcomes—to connect events at distant locations in a way that cannot be explained by influences traveling locally from the past.

This is not the name of one specific theory. It is a broad description of theories that reject Bell locality. Bohmian mechanics, also called pilot-wave theory, is a well-known example.

What makes a hidden-variable theory local?

Imagine two particles created together and sent to distant experimenters, Alice and Bob. Each chooses a measurement setting, written aa for Alice and bb for Bob, and records an outcome, AA or BB. A hidden variable, written λ\lambda, represents additional information about the pair that is not included in the usual quantum state.

In a Bell-local model, once the shared hidden information is specified, the two outcomes are statistically independent of each other. The joint probability must factorize:

P(A,B∣a,b,λ)=P(A∣a,λ)P(B∣b,λ).P(A,B\mid a,b,\lambda)=P(A\mid a,\lambda)P(B\mid b,\lambda).

In plain language, Alice’s outcome can depend on her setting and the shared past, but not on Bob’s setting; Bob’s outcome obeys the corresponding rule. This condition is often called Bell locality or local causality. It is stronger than simply saying that no usable message travels faster than light.

A non-local hidden-variable model allows the factorization to fail. For example, its rule for Alice’s outcome might depend on both aa and bb, even when the measurements are spacelike separated. That dependence is a feature of the model, not necessarily a controllable signal sent from Bob to Alice.

What Bell’s theorem shows

Bell’s theorem establishes that a model satisfying Bell locality, together with standard assumptions such as independently chosen measurement settings, must obey certain limits on correlations. The CHSH form of a Bell inequality is:

∣S∣≤2,|S|\leq 2,

where SS combines four correlations measured using two possible settings per experimenter. Quantum mechanics predicts—and experiments observe—correlations that can exceed 2. Therefore, a theory that reproduces these results cannot satisfy all the assumptions used to derive the inequality. In particular, it cannot be both Bell-local and compatible with the observed correlations, assuming the measurement settings are independent of the hidden variables.

This does not show that hidden variables are impossible. It shows that local hidden-variable theories of the relevant kind cannot reproduce the full pattern of quantum correlations. Other assumptions can also be questioned, but abandoning Bell locality is the route taken by familiar non-local hidden-variable accounts.

Worked example: singlet-state correlations

For two spin-12\frac{1}{2} particles in a singlet state, quantum mechanics predicts that the correlation for spin measurements along directions aa and bb is

E(a,b)=−a⋅b.E(a,b)=-a\cdot b.

Choose Alice’s two directions as a0=za_0=z and a1=xa_1=x. Choose Bob’s directions as b0=(z+x)/2b_0=(z+x)/\sqrt{2} and b1=(z−x)/2b_1=(z-x)/\sqrt{2}. The four predicted correlations are

E(a0,b0)=−1/2,E(a0,b1)=−1/2,E(a1,b0)=−1/2,E(a1,b1)=+1/2.\begin{aligned} E(a_0,b_0)&=-1/\sqrt{2}, & E(a_0,b_1)&=-1/\sqrt{2},\\ E(a_1,b_0)&=-1/\sqrt{2}, & E(a_1,b_1)&=+1/\sqrt{2}. \end{aligned}

Using the CHSH combination S=E(a0,b0)+E(a0,b1)+E(a1,b0)−E(a1,b1)S=E(a_0,b_0)+E(a_0,b_1)+E(a_1,b_0)-E(a_1,b_1) gives S=−22S=-2\sqrt{2}, so ∣S∣=22≈2.83|S|=2\sqrt{2}\approx 2.83. This is greater than the local bound of 2. The example shows how quantum correlations rule out Bell-local models, not that either particle can be used to send a message to the other.

A familiar example: Bohmian mechanics

In Bohmian mechanics, particles have definite positions, and a wave function guides their motion. For an entangled system, the guiding equation for one particle can depend on the configuration of the other particle, even when the particles are far apart. This makes the theory non-local in Bell’s sense.

Bohmian mechanics is deterministic at the level of its underlying dynamics, but its predictions in quantum equilibrium agree with ordinary quantum mechanics. In that equilibrium, the non-local dependence does not provide a way to control distant outcomes and transmit information faster than light. Other approaches may explain Bell correlations differently; Bell violations alone do not select Bohmian mechanics as the correct interpretation.

Common mistakes

  • Treating “non-local” as synonymous with “faster-than-light communication.” Bell non-locality concerns correlations or dependencies in a theory. Quantum mechanics still obeys the no-signaling condition: changing one experimenter’s setting cannot be used to control the other’s local outcome statistics.
  • Assuming Bell’s theorem disproves every hidden-variable theory. It rules out theories that satisfy the theorem’s assumptions and reproduce the relevant quantum predictions. A non-local theory avoids the local bound by rejecting Bell locality.
  • Assuming every interpretation uses hidden variables. Many interpretations do not add hidden variables, and they need not explain Bell correlations using the same mechanism.
  • Confusing ordinary locality with Bell locality. A theory may have no controllable faster-than-light signals and still be non-local in Bell’s technical sense.

The central point is that Bell experiments constrain how any successful account of entanglement can work. If it uses hidden variables and matches the observed correlations, it must give up Bell locality or reject another assumption in the theorem.

References

  1. On the Einstein Podolsky Rosen Paradox — John S. Bell
  2. Speakable and Unspeakable in Quantum Mechanics — John S. Bell
  3. The Undivided Universe: An Ontological Interpretation of Quantum Theory — David Bohm and Basil J. Hiley

Spotted an error? Send a correction. Read how we write and check articles in our editorial policy.