How Do You Find the Time Difference Between Moving Frames?
At a glance
- 1. Choose the events
Specify which two events you are comparing; a time difference is defined between events, not between frames by itself.
- 2. Set the frames
State their relative speed and which frame is S and which is S′.
- 3. Use Lorentz time
Apply the time-coordinate transformation, including the spatial separation of the events.
- 4. Check the special case
For events at one place in a frame, use time dilation; for separated events, account for relativity of simultaneity.
Two inertial frames do not each have a single clock reading that can be subtracted to produce a universal “time difference.” To calculate a time interval, first identify the two events you mean. Different event pairs can give different answers, even for the same pair of frames.
The Lorentz transformation gives the relation between their time coordinates. It also explains why time dilation and relativity of simultaneity are related but distinct effects.
The time-coordinate transformation
Let frame move at constant speed in the positive direction relative to frame . Choose the origins so they coincide at . The time coordinates of an event are related by
where is the speed of light. For two events, subtract their coordinates:
Here, and are measured in . The term involving matters whenever the events occur at different positions in . Thus, knowing only the relative speed and one frame’s time interval is not enough in general; you also need the events’ spatial separation.
When time dilation applies
Suppose the two events occur at the same position in , so . They could be two ticks of a clock at rest in . The interval is then the clock’s proper time, the time measured by a clock present at both events. The inverse Lorentz transformation gives
The frame in which the clock moves assigns a longer interval between those same two tick events. This is time dilation. It is not a claim that all time intervals in are simply times all intervals in ; that shortcut works for events at the same place in the clock’s rest frame.
Worked example: a moving clock
A clock is at rest in and measures 10 seconds between two ticks. The frames move relative to one another at . First calculate
Because the ticks happen at the same place in the clock’s rest frame, . Therefore the interval assigned by is
So measures 10 seconds between the ticks, while assigns 12.5 seconds between those same events. The ticks occur at different positions in , because the clock is moving there.
Why the time dilation is reciprocal
An observer in can also say that clocks at rest in are moving and run slow. This is not a contradiction. The two statements compare different pairs of events: each observer’s “moving clock” comparison selects events at the moving clock’s location, and the observers disagree about which spatially separated events are simultaneous.
For instance, simultaneity in means . For two separated events in , the transformation gives
which is generally not zero. Events that are simultaneous in one frame need not be simultaneous in another. This is the relativity of simultaneity, and it is essential when comparing clocks at different locations.
Common mistakes
- Asking for a frame-to-frame time difference without naming events. Frames have coordinate systems; a time interval belongs to a specified pair of events.
- Using for any two events. This formula applies when the events occur at the same position in . Otherwise, use the full Lorentz transformation.
- Treating simultaneous events as simultaneous in every frame. For spatially separated events, simultaneity depends on the frame.
- Mixing up proper time and coordinate time. Proper time is measured by a clock present at both events. Coordinate time is assigned using a frame’s synchronized clocks.
To solve a particular problem, write down the two events, their position and time differences in a known frame, and the relative velocity. Then use the Lorentz transformation with a consistent direction convention for .
References
- Spacetime Physics: Introduction to Special Relativity, Edwin F. Taylor and John Archibald Wheeler
- The Feynman Lectures on Physics, Volume I, Chapter 15: The Special Theory of Relativity
Spotted an error? Send a correction. Read how we write and check articles in our editorial policy.