Ph · Physics

Thermal Energy vs Internal Energy: What Is the Difference?

Published By the 9to5Science editorial team

At a glance

  1. 1. Define internal energy

    Internal energy is the microscopic energy stored in a system, including molecular motion and interactions.

  2. 2. Interpret thermal energy

    Thermal energy is an informal term, often meaning the part of internal energy associated with random microscopic motion.

  3. 3. Separate heat from energy

    Heat is energy transferred because of a temperature difference; it is not energy contained in an object.

  4. 4. Use the first law

    Track changes with ΔU = Q − W, while remembering that internal energy can change through work as well as heat.

Advertisement

The terms thermal energy and internal energy are often used interchangeably in introductory physics, but they are not equally precise. Internal energy has a standard thermodynamic meaning. Thermal energy is an informal term whose meaning depends on the textbook or context.

The safest distinction is this: internal energy is a property stored in a system, whereas heat is energy transferred to or from a system. Thermal energy usually refers to microscopic energy related to temperature, and sometimes to all of a system’s internal energy.

What is internal energy?

The internal energy, denoted by UU, is the energy associated with the microscopic contents of a system. It includes, for example:

  • the random translational, rotational, and vibrational motion of atoms and molecules;
  • intermolecular and interatomic potential energy;
  • chemical-bond energy;
  • energy associated with changes of phase;
  • electronic, nuclear, and other microscopic forms of energy, when relevant.

It does not include the kinetic energy of the system’s motion as a whole or its macroscopic gravitational potential energy. For a moving object, the total energy can be separated schematically as

E=U+Kbulk+Epotential+⋯E = U + K_{\text{bulk}} + E_{\text{potential}} + \cdots

For example, a moving tennis ball has internal energy because its molecules are moving and interacting. It also has bulk kinetic energy because the ball as a whole is moving. Increasing the ball’s speed does not, by itself, increase its internal energy.

Internal energy is a state function: its change depends only on the initial and final states, not on the path taken between them.

What does thermal energy mean?

“Thermal energy” has no single universally accepted technical definition. In many educational contexts, it means the microscopic kinetic energy associated with random molecular motion. Under that usage, thermal energy is only one contribution to internal energy.

In other contexts, especially elementary discussions, “thermal energy” is used as a simpler name for the total internal energy of a substance. That convention is not necessarily wrong, but it can hide distinctions that matter in thermodynamics.

A useful practical interpretation is:

TermMeaning
Internal energyPrecise thermodynamic quantity containing microscopic kinetic and interaction energies
Thermal energyInformal term usually referring to energy associated with random microscopic motion, or sometimes to internal energy as a whole
HeatEnergy transferred because of a temperature difference
TemperatureAn intensive equilibrium state variable that characterizes the microscopic energy distribution, not the total energy stored

Thus, if a problem requires a thermodynamic calculation, use UU and specify what forms of microscopic energy are included rather than relying on “thermal energy.”

Heat is not the same as internal energy

A system contains internal energy, but it does not “contain heat” in the thermodynamic sense. Heat, written as QQ, describes energy crossing the boundary of a system because of a temperature difference.

The first law of thermodynamics makes the distinction explicit. For a closed system, meaning a fixed amount of matter, and with the convention that WW is work done by the system,

ΔU=Q−W\Delta U = Q - W

Internal energy can therefore change in two main ways:

  1. Energy can enter or leave as heat.
  2. Work can be done on or by the system.

If a gas is compressed quickly in an insulated cylinder, Q=0Q=0, but work is done on the gas. Its internal energy and temperature can increase even though no heat entered. Conversely, a gas can expand and do work, reducing its internal energy even if it receives some heat.

Worked example: heating and compressing a gas

Suppose a gas receives 500 J500\ \text{J} of heat while it does 200 J200\ \text{J} of work on a piston. The change in internal energy is

ΔU=Q−W=500 J−200 J=300 J.\begin{aligned} \Delta U &= Q-W\\ &=500\ \text{J}-200\ \text{J}\\ &=300\ \text{J}. \end{aligned}

The gas has gained 300 J300\ \text{J} of internal energy. The full 500 J500\ \text{J} did not remain inside it: 200 J200\ \text{J} was transferred out as work.

If instead 200 J200\ \text{J} of work were done on the gas and it received 500 J500\ \text{J} of heat, then W=−200 JW=-200\ \text{J} under the same convention:

ΔU=500 J−(−200 J)=700 J.\Delta U = 500\ \text{J}-(-200\ \text{J})=700\ \text{J}.

The sign of work depends on the convention, so always state whether WW means work done by or on the system.

Temperature does not determine total thermal or internal energy

Temperature and internal energy are related, but they are not the same quantity. Temperature is an intensive property: it does not depend on how much substance is present. Internal energy is generally extensive: doubling the amount of substance approximately doubles its internal energy at the same temperature and state.

For instance, a cup of water and a swimming pool can both be at 20∘C20^\circ\text{C}. The pool has much more internal energy because it contains far more water, even though their temperatures are equal.

The type of substance also matters. A kilogram of metal and a kilogram of water at the same temperature can have different internal energies relative to a chosen reference because their molecular structures and interaction energies differ.

Internal energy during a phase change

During melting or boiling at a fixed pressure, a substance can absorb energy without increasing its temperature. The supplied energy changes the microscopic arrangement and separation of particles, so it increases internal energy even while the temperature remains constant.

For an equilibrium phase change carried out at fixed pressure, the heat supplied in the usual latent-heat idealization is

Q=mLQ=mL

where mm is the mass and LL is the specific latent heat for that transition at the specified pressure. For a closed system with only pVpV work, this constant-pressure heat generally corresponds to an enthalpy change, so it need not equal ΔU\Delta U when expansion work is significant. If work is negligible and there is no other energy transfer, then this heat increases UU:

ΔU≈Q=mL.\Delta U \approx Q=mL.

This is one reason “thermal energy equals energy of molecular motion” is incomplete: internal energy also includes interaction and phase-related energy.

Common mistakes

Calling heat something an object contains

Say that an object has internal energy. Say that heat is transferred to or from it.

Treating thermal energy as a rigorously defined universal quantity

Check the context. In formal thermodynamics, use internal energy unless the source explicitly defines thermal energy.

Assuming higher temperature means more total energy

A small hot object can have less internal energy than a large cooler object. Amount of substance and material properties matter.

Ignoring work

A system’s internal energy can change without heat transfer, such as during adiabatic compression or expansion.

Assuming all internal energy is molecular translational energy

Interactions, vibrations, rotations, chemical bonds, electronic states, and phase changes can all contribute.

For most introductory questions, the reliable wording is: thermal energy is an informal term for microscopic energy associated with temperature, while internal energy is the complete thermodynamic microscopic energy of the system. Heat is the transfer of energy caused by a temperature difference.

References

  1. Thermal Physics, by Charles Kittel and Herbert Kroemer
  2. Fundamentals of Physics, by David Halliday, Robert Resnick, and Jearl Walker
  3. Thermodynamics: An Engineering Approach, by Yunus A. Çengel and Michael A. Boles

Spotted an error? Send a correction. Read how we write and check articles in our editorial policy.