What Are the Largest Gaps in the History of Mathematics?
At a glance
- 1. Define the gap
Separate long waits for a proof from gaps in transmission or historical records.
- 2. Compare dated problems
Use a stated starting point and a stated milestone, such as the first proof announcement.
- 3. Keep the caveats
Dates and meanings vary, and unsolved problems have no completed waiting time.
“The largest gaps” in mathematics can mean several different things. The most measurable are long intervals between a problem’s formulation and a proof. Other candidates are periods when mathematical work is poorly documented, or when ideas developed in one culture reached another much later. These are not directly comparable, so no definitive ranking exists.
A useful way to compare famous examples is to state exactly what is being timed: the date a problem was posed, and the date a proof was announced, published, or accepted. By that measure, several waits lasted centuries.
Long waits from problem to proof
| Problem or result | Starting point | Proof milestone | Approximate wait |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kepler conjecture | 1611 | Hales announced a proof in 1998 | 387 years |
| Fermat’s Last Theorem | 1637 | Wiles announced a corrected proof in 1994, after an initial 1993 announcement | 357 years |
| Four color problem | 1852 | Appel and Haken announced a proof in 1976 | 124 years |
| Poincaré conjecture | 1904 | Perelman posted a proof in 2002–03 | About 98 years |
These numbers are approximate historical intervals, not measurements of continuous effort. Mathematicians did not work on every problem without interruption for the whole period. A conjecture can be known only to a small circle, receive little attention, or become approachable only after new techniques emerge.
The Kepler conjecture: about 387 years
In 1611, Johannes Kepler conjectured that the familiar way of stacking cannonballs gives the densest possible packing of equal spheres in three-dimensional space. Thomas Hales announced a proof in 1998; the journal proof appeared in 2005. A computer-assisted formal verification of the proof was completed in 2014.
The interval depends on which milestone counts as “solved.” From the conjecture to the announcement is about 387 years; to the journal publication, about 394; and to formal verification, about 403. This is a good example of why a gap needs a defined endpoint.
Fermat’s Last Theorem: about 357 years
Pierre de Fermat wrote in 1637 that he had a proof that no positive integers satisfy for an integer exponent , but that the margin was too small to contain it. Andrew Wiles announced an initial proof in 1993. A gap was found; Wiles repaired it with Richard Taylor and announced a corrected proof in 1994, which was published in 1995.
Counting to the corrected-proof announcement gives about 357 years; counting to publication gives about 358. Fermat’s note is the usual starting date, though it does not establish that he had a valid proof.
The four color problem: 124 years
In 1852, Francis Guthrie asked whether every planar map could be colored with at most four colors so that neighboring regions have different colors. The problem was proved in 1976 by Kenneth Appel and Wolfgang Haken, using extensive computer checking. The proof’s reliance on computation made it especially influential in discussions of what counts as an acceptable mathematical proof.
The Poincaré conjecture: about 98 years
Henri Poincaré posed the conjecture in 1904. It concerns the characterization of the three-dimensional sphere through topological properties. Grigori Perelman posted papers giving a proof in 2002 and 2003, building on Richard Hamilton’s Ricci-flow program. The proof was checked and accepted by the mathematical community over the following years; there is no single announcement date that captures the whole process.
Gaps in mathematical transmission
A different kind of gap occurs when ideas are developed in one place but become known elsewhere much later. Greek mathematical works were translated and studied by scholars writing in Arabic, and some reached Latin-speaking Europe through later translation movements. This was not a simple disappearance followed by a rediscovery: mathematical knowledge continued to develop across cultures, and transmission took place through many routes.
The history of the parallel postulate offers another kind of long interval. For roughly two millennia, mathematicians tried to derive Euclid’s fifth postulate from his other assumptions. In the early nineteenth century, Nikolai Lobachevsky and János Bolyai developed geometries in which the postulate does not hold. The “gap” here is not a wait for a proof of the old goal; it is the time before mathematicians recognized that changing the assumption could produce a consistent geometry.
Why a single “largest” gap is misleading
The ranking changes with the definition. Counting from a conjecture’s earliest surviving written mention may differ from counting from its modern formulation. A proof announcement, peer-reviewed publication, community acceptance, and formal verification are distinct milestones. And an open problem has no completed gap at all: its waiting time keeps growing.
There are also many areas of mathematics, and a famous problem’s long history does not necessarily mean it was the most difficult or important. New concepts and methods often turn an apparently unreachable problem into a tractable one. The examples above are best read as well-known, dated waits—not as an objective leaderboard of mathematical achievement.
Common mistakes when comparing historical gaps
- Treating the whole interval as continuous work. A problem may lie dormant for decades or centuries.
- Mixing different endpoints. An announcement and a published or formally verified proof are not the same milestone.
- Assuming old conjectures were precisely modern problems. The statement may have changed as mathematical language and standards developed.
- Calling cultural transmission a blank period. Sparse records or delayed translation do not mean that no mathematics was being done.
References
- Mathematics and Its History — John Stillwell
- The Kepler Conjecture — Thomas C. Hales, The Annals of Mathematics
- Modular Elliptic Curves and Fermat’s Last Theorem — Andrew Wiles, The Annals of Mathematics
Spotted an error? Send a correction. Read how we write and check articles in our editorial policy.