How Grothendieck Vanishing Gives a Strict Degree Bound
At a glance
- 1. Check the dimension
Let d be the dimension of the noetherian scheme, or the dimension of the support of the coherent sheaf.
- 2. Apply vanishing
Grothendieck vanishing says the cohomology groups vanish in every degree i greater than d.
- 3. Read the inequality
The theorem excludes degrees above d; it does not generally exclude degree d itself.
- 4. Check sharpness
A projective plane example has nonzero second cohomology, showing the dimension bound can be attained.
Grothendieck vanishing is a statement about which degrees of sheaf cohomology can be nonzero. For a coherent sheaf on a noetherian scheme, cohomology vanishes strictly above the dimension of its support. The strict inequality matters: the theorem does not generally say that cohomology vanishes in the top degree itself.
The theorem and its bound
Let be a noetherian scheme and let be a coherent sheaf on . A standard form of Grothendieck’s vanishing theorem states that
In particular, since , this implies
If , the theorem rules out nonzero cohomology in degrees . Equivalently, the cohomological dimension for this sheaf is at most . It does not assert that the cohomological dimension is strictly less than : may be nonzero.
The support version can give a stronger result when the sheaf is concentrated on a smaller closed subset. For example, if has dimension but is supported on a closed subset of dimension , then the theorem gives vanishing for every .
How to use the strict inequality
To apply the theorem in a problem, identify the relevant dimension and compare it with the degree you want to rule out:
- Check that the hypotheses apply, usually that is noetherian and is coherent.
- Find ; using also gives a valid, possibly weaker, bound.
- If the degree satisfies , conclude directly that .
- If , the theorem alone gives no conclusion. You need another argument or a stronger hypothesis.
The cohomology degree is an integer. Thus saying “vanishes for ” means the first excluded degree is , not .
Worked example: the bound can be sharp
Take , the projective plane over a field , and let . Here , so Grothendieck vanishing guarantees
But the top-degree group is nonzero. Serre duality on gives
So the cohomology does not vanish in degree . This example shows why “strict bound” should be read as vanishing above the dimension, not as vanishing at or above it.
Common mistakes
- Replacing with . This strengthens the theorem and is generally false, as the projective-plane example shows.
- Confusing a bound with an exact value. The theorem gives an upper bound on possible nonzero degrees; it does not guarantee that the top allowed group is nonzero.
- Using the dimension of when the support is smaller. The support form can give a sharper bound.
- Ignoring hypotheses or changing settings. The statement quoted here is the standard coherent-sheaf version for noetherian schemes. If a problem concerns a different kind of space or sheaf, check the version of the vanishing theorem that applies before using the same bound.
For comparison, if is affine and is quasi-coherent, the stronger affine vanishing theorem gives for every . That is a different result and can be stronger than the dimension bound.
References
- Robin Hartshorne, Algebraic Geometry, Chapter III, Theorem 2.7
- The Stacks Project, Cohomology of Schemes
Spotted an error? Send a correction. Read how we write and check articles in our editorial policy.