Ma · Mathematics

Example: A Product Limit Exists Even When Neither Factor Limit Does

Published By the 9to5Science editorial team

At a glance

  1. 1. Choose an oscillating factor

    Let f(x) = 2 + sin(1/(x − a)) for x ≠ a. Its values keep oscillating near a.

  2. 2. Take its reciprocal

    Define g(x) = 1/f(x). Since f stays between 1 and 3, g is defined and also oscillates.

  3. 3. Multiply the factors

    For every x ≠ a, f(x)g(x) = 1, so the product limit is 1.

  4. 4. Verify nonexistence

    Use two sequences approaching a where the sine equals 1 and −1. Each factor has different subsequential values.

A product can have a limit even when neither factor has one. The key is that the factors can vary in opposite ways, so their changes cancel when you multiply them.

A concrete example

Fix any real number aa. For x≠ax \ne a, define

f(x)=2+sin⁡(1x−a),g(x)=12+sin⁡(1x−a).f(x)=2+\sin\left(\frac{1}{x-a}\right), \qquad g(x)=\frac{1}{2+\sin\left(\frac{1}{x-a}\right)}.

At x=ax=a, assign any values to f(a)f(a) and g(a)g(a); those values do not affect limits as xx approaches aa. The denominator in gg is never zero: since −1≤sin⁡t≤1-1 \le \sin t \le 1, the denominator lies between 11 and 33.

For every x≠ax \ne a, the factors are reciprocals, so

f(x)g(x)=(2+sin⁡(1x−a))12+sin⁡(1x−a)=1.f(x)g(x)=\left(2+\sin\left(\frac{1}{x-a}\right)\right)\frac{1}{2+\sin\left(\frac{1}{x-a}\right)}=1.

Thus the product is identically 11 throughout a punctured neighborhood of aa, and

lim⁡x→af(x)g(x)=1.\lim_{x\to a} f(x)g(x)=1.

Why neither factor has a limit

As xx approaches aa, the quantity 1/(x−a)1/(x-a) becomes unbounded and the sine term keeps oscillating. To verify that this prevents a limit, choose two sequences approaching aa from the right:

xn=a+1π2+2πn,yn=a+13π2+2πn.x_n=a+\frac{1}{\frac{\pi}{2}+2\pi n}, \qquad y_n=a+\frac{1}{\frac{3\pi}{2}+2\pi n}.

Both sequences tend to aa. For the first, sin⁡(1/(xn−a))=1\sin(1/(x_n-a))=1, so f(xn)=3f(x_n)=3 and g(xn)=1/3g(x_n)=1/3. For the second, sin⁡(1/(yn−a))=−1\sin(1/(y_n-a))=-1, so f(yn)=1f(y_n)=1 and g(yn)=1g(y_n)=1.

A function with a limit at aa must approach the same value along every sequence tending to aa. Here, ff takes the distinct subsequential values 33 and 11, while gg takes 1/31/3 and 11. Consequently, neither lim⁡x→af(x)\lim_{x\to a} f(x) nor lim⁡x→ag(x)\lim_{x\to a} g(x) exists. Yet on both sequences, as everywhere else with x≠ax\ne a, the product remains 11.

What the example shows

The product limit law says that if both factor limits exist as finite real numbers, then the product limit is the product of those limits. It does not say that the existence of the product limit forces the individual limits to exist. In this example, the factors are bounded and oscillate in a coordinated way: whenever one factor increases, the reciprocal factor decreases to compensate.

The limit of a product depends on the values of the product near aa, not on whether each factor settles to a value separately. Knowing only that f(x)g(x)f(x)g(x) approaches a number therefore does not let you conclude that either factor has a limit.

Common mistakes

  • Choosing two oscillating factors whose product still oscillates. For instance, setting both factors equal to sin⁡(1/(x−a))\sin(1/(x-a)) gives the product sin⁡2(1/(x−a))\sin^2(1/(x-a)), which has no limit: it takes values 00 and 11 along sequences approaching aa.
  • Using a reciprocal with a zero denominator. The choice f(x)=sin⁡(1/(x−a))f(x)=\sin(1/(x-a)) and g(x)=1/f(x)g(x)=1/f(x) fails because ff is zero at infinitely many points near aa. Shifting the sine by 22 keeps the factor strictly positive and makes the reciprocal well-defined.
  • Thinking the function values at aa decide the limit. A limit concerns values near aa, excluding aa itself. Changing either function’s value at aa does not change the result.
  • Checking only one sequence. One sequence can show what a limit would have to be, but a second sequence with a different function value is what proves that the limit does not exist.

Spotted an error? Send a correction. Read how we write and check articles in our editorial policy.