Probability that centre of the square lies inside the circle joining the two points inside the square


Solution 1

Call the first point A, the second point B, and the center O. Join the line AO, and extend a line DOE through O, perpendicular to AO and continuing in both directions. If B is on the other side of DOE from A, then the circle joining A and B will contain the center. If B is on the same side of the line as A, then it will not. The line bisects the square's area, so the probability is 1/2.

Solution 2

Although the answer has already been given, it's possible to check this via simulation. In R:

n = 10^8
x1 = runif(n, 0, 1)
x2 = runif(n, 0, 1)
y1 = runif(n, 0, 1)
y2 = runif(n, 0, 1) = (x1+x2)/2 = (y1+y2)/2
radius = sqrt((^2+(^2) = sqrt((^2+(^2)
sum(radius >

This simulates drawing $10^8$ pairs of points

(x1, y1), (x2, y2)
, and finds the center and radius of the corresponding circles, and checks to see whether those circles contain the center of the square (1/2, 1/2). When I ran this I got 49995062, meaning that the probability can be estimated as 0.49995062. I'd say that's close to 1/2.


Related videos on Youtube

Rahul Sharma
Author by

Rahul Sharma

Updated on September 18, 2021


  • Rahul Sharma
    Rahul Sharma about 2 years

    Two points are uniformly and independently distributed (located) inside a square. A circle is drawn such that the segment joining the two points is a diameter. Find the probability that the center of the square lies inside that circle.

    • Michael Albanese
      Michael Albanese about 10 years
      How do you draw a circle from two points? Do you make the line segment joining them the diameter of the circle with centre at the midpoint?
    • Maxim Umansky
      Maxim Umansky about 10 years
      If the radius of the circle is another independent random parameter then we need to know how it is distributed.
    • Rahul Sharma
      Rahul Sharma about 10 years
      Sorry for the above comment!!! line segment joining those two points forms the diameter of the circle.
  • Rahul Sharma
    Rahul Sharma about 10 years
    can you please elaborate on the geometry part that how will the circle contain the center of the square if A and B are on opposite sides of the line DOE.
  • achille hui
    achille hui about 10 years
    @RahulSharma Choose the coordinate system such that $O$ is the origin, observe $$\left|\;\vec{0} - \frac{\vec{A}+\vec{B}}{2}\;\right| \le \frac{|\vec{A}-\vec{B}|}{2} \iff \vec{A}\cdot \vec{B} \le 0 $$
  • leonbloy
    leonbloy about 10 years
    To put it other way: 1) the circle does not cover $O$ iff the angle $\widehat{AOB}$ is acute. 2) The probability that $\widehat{AOB}$ is acute is 1/2
  • achille hui
    achille hui about 10 years
    @leonbloy I like your geometric argument.
  • G Tony Jacobs
    G Tony Jacobs about 10 years
    Fix a circle with diameter AB, and try placing O in different locations: outside the circle, on the circumference of the circle, inside the circle. What can you say about angle AOB in each of the three cases?
  • Rahul Sharma
    Rahul Sharma about 10 years
    @leonbloy: thanks, got it :)