Ch · Chemistry

How to Find Partial Atomic Charges in GAMESS

Published By the 9to5Science editorial team

At a glance

  1. 1. Run the calculation

    Use your chosen method, basis set, molecular geometry, total charge, and spin multiplicity.

  2. 2. Find the populations

    Search the GAMESS output file for the Mulliken atomic population analysis.

  3. 3. Convert to charge

    For each atom, subtract its electron population from its nuclear charge.

  4. 4. Check the sum

    The atomic charges should add to the molecule’s total charge, subject to printed rounding.

GAMESS can report atomic electron populations that you can convert to partial atomic charges. In the usual case, look for the Mulliken atomic population analysis in the output file. The key conversion is the same regardless of whether you run Hartree–Fock or density functional theory: an atom’s partial charge is its nuclear charge minus its assigned electron population.

These values are a way to describe how electron density is distributed among atoms. They are not unique, directly measurable charges: different population-analysis methods can assign different values to the same molecule.

Find the Mulliken analysis in the output

Run your GAMESS calculation and search the output file for MULLIKEN. GAMESS reports an electron population for each atom in its population analysis. Some output formats also show a charge column directly; if yours does, check that it follows the sign convention below. The electron population and the partial charge are related, but they are not the same quantity.

A basic closed-shell DFT input might include lines like these:

 $CONTRL SCFTYP=RHF RUNTYP=ENERGY DFTTYP=B3LYP ICHARG=0 MULT=1 $END
 $BASIS GBASIS=N31 NGAUSS=6 $END
 $DATA
Water
C1
O  8.0  0.000000  0.000000  0.000000
H  1.0  0.000000  0.757000  0.586000
H  1.0  0.000000 -0.757000  0.586000
 $END

This specifies a neutral singlet water molecule and a 6-31G basis. It is only an example of a calculation setup; the exact geometry, method, basis set, and charge should match your system. The population analysis is generally part of the standard output, so you typically do not need a special keyword just to obtain Mulliken populations. If the section is missing, check whether your run completed normally and whether output-printing settings suppress population information.

Convert populations to partial charges

For atom AA, use

qA=ZA−NA,q_A = Z_A - N_A,

where ZAZ_A is the atom’s nuclear charge (its atomic number) and NAN_A is its Mulliken electron population. A positive result means the analysis assigns the atom fewer electrons than its neutral atom; a negative result means it assigns more.

For example, suppose a population analysis assigns an oxygen atom 8.4 electrons and each of two hydrogen atoms 0.8 electrons. These are illustrative numbers, not claimed results for the sample input. Oxygen has Z=8Z=8, and hydrogen has Z=1Z=1, so:

qO=8−8.4=−0.4,qH1=1−0.8=+0.2,qH2=1−0.8=+0.2.\begin{aligned} q_{\mathrm{O}} &= 8 - 8.4 = -0.4,\\ q_{\mathrm{H}_1} &= 1 - 0.8 = +0.2,\\ q_{\mathrm{H}_2} &= 1 - 0.8 = +0.2. \end{aligned}

The charges sum to −0.4+0.2+0.2=0-0.4 + 0.2 + 0.2 = 0, consistent with neutral water. For an ion with total charge QQ, the atomic charges should instead sum to QQ.

Check the result and choose a charge model

Use the total-charge check as a quick way to catch a sign error or a misread output column:

∑AqA=Q.\sum_A q_A = Q.

Small differences can occur because the output rounds populations or charges. If the discrepancy is larger than rounding can explain, confirm that you used the intended molecular charge, read the correct population-analysis section, and included every atom.

Mulliken charges are convenient, but they can vary substantially with the basis set because the method divides electron density associated with overlapping basis functions among atoms. Other schemes, such as Löwdin population analysis or charges fitted to the molecular electrostatic potential, use different definitions and can give different numbers. State which scheme you used when reporting charges, and do not compare values from different schemes as though they were identical quantities.

Common mistakes

  • Treating electron populations as charges. An oxygen population of 8.4 means its Mulliken charge is 8−8.4=−0.48 - 8.4 = -0.4, not +8.4+8.4.
  • Reversing the subtraction. Use nuclear charge minus electron population, not the other way around.
  • Expecting a unique partial charge. Partial charges depend on the chosen partitioning method and, for Mulliken analysis, can be sensitive to the basis set.
  • Ignoring the molecular charge. Atomic charges should add to the specified total molecular charge, not necessarily to zero.
  • Reporting too many digits. The displayed precision does not make a basis- and method-dependent charge exact. Report sensible precision and name the charge scheme.

References

  1. GAMESS User’s Guide
  2. R. S. Mulliken, “Electronic Population Analysis on LCAO–MO Molecular Wave Functions”

Spotted an error? Send a correction. Read how we write and check articles in our editorial policy.