Math terminology: What are rules regarding hyphens? (Nonzero vs. non-zero)

8,161

Solution 1

Since many (or a nonnegligible amount) of authors just do not care, I guess it's up to personal preference. However, there is a semantic code, like pointed out here. Thereafter, the prefix non is not hyphenated. And I really think this should be consistent. I had nonzero, nonempty and nonholonomic occuring in my thesis and it was "corrected" by different supervisors into different versions, mostly where non-holonomic was hyphenated and the rest not. I really think this is bad practice, since consistency is lost by this "to highlight" mentality. If on tries to highlight something, why not explain it and treat it consistently in semantics.

To underline my point consider using $X$ for vectors in one direction. For some other vector, to hightlight that it's not in this direction you use $\alpha$. But why not $Y$ with an explanation?! Therefore, semantics is consistent and the highlights are where they belong, in the "comments".

What got me to enforce this was that every title I cited contained the nonhyphenated versions of all those words. Thus, (from a far too small sample, but of good works) I conclude that this is common practice in this field (between robotics and automation).

Oxford Dictionary also advises to use hyphens for prefixes, which lead to vowel collisions, like pre-advised, although nothing further is stated there.

Solution 2

Donald Knuth says we should drop the hyphens.

Here is the link to his post in which he says so:

https://cs.stanford.edu/~knuth/email.html

Share:
8,161

Related videos on Youtube

Xoque55
Author by

Xoque55

Updated on August 01, 2022

Comments

  • Xoque55
    Xoque55 over 1 year

    This question is geared toward clarifying terminology in writing math.

    Which terms are correct and why?

    1. A set $E$ is non-empty.
    2. A set $E$ is nonempty.

    1. The number $x$ is non-negative.
    2. The number $x$ is nonnegative.

    1. The number $y$ is non-positive.
    2. The number $y$ is nonpositive.

    1. The number $z$ is non-zero.
    2. The number $z$ is nonzero.

    As a personal preference, I like the way nonzero looks but I prefer to use non-empty so I don't know what the consistency with hyphens is when prefixing "non". I also like the way nonnegative reads but I feel like non-positive looks better than without a hyphen. I don't have any rhyme or reason why I have these preferences and that's why I'm curious to learn if there is a correct version of each term listed above.

    • Fizz
      Fizz almost 9 years
      This would be more suitable on english.stackexchange.com as the word-formation rules probably don't have much to do with actual math.
    • Git Gud
      Git Gud almost 9 years
      I'd be surprised if the technicality of the terms is relevant to answer this question. Have you tried asking at English Language S.E. or English Language Learners S.E.?
    • Xoque55
      Xoque55 almost 9 years
      @RespawnedFluff I considered that SE but I figured that mathematicians would have more familiarity seeing these terms and have a better sense of which one is more common or be able to give reasons why they prefer/avoid hyphens.
    • achille hui
      achille hui almost 9 years
      I'll just do whatever that pleases the spell checker I'm using and concentrate on the real math. Only when it get to the point to get something published, you ask your secretary or English major friend for proof reading.
    • Fizz
      Fizz almost 9 years
      Maybe someone can actually provide info if the major math publishing houses, like AMS, Springer etc., have any rules or preferences expressed in some style document of theirs.
    • Brian M. Scott
      Brian M. Scott almost 9 years
      Both are generally accepted. I much prefer and always use the hyphenated versions.
    • bof
      bof over 7 years
      I use hyphens before capital letters, so "non-Abelian" instead of "nonAbelian".
    • Admin
      Admin over 7 years
    • GEdgar
      GEdgar over 7 years
      Once long ago, an AMS journal corrected "non-negtive" to "nonnegative" in a paper of mine, so I have used it (and similar spellings) ever since.
    • Calmarius
      Calmarius about 4 years
      My spellchecker underlines nonzero and suggests fixing it to non-zero.
    • john c. j.
      john c. j. over 3 years
      This link says it is better to write "nonempty", no hyphen or space: groups.google.com/forum/#!topic/misc.education.language.engl‌​ish/…
  • Fizz
    Fizz almost 9 years
    If I search in Google Books "non-negative" vs. "nonnegative" they're about tied, and the top hits are all math books for both searches.
  • bof
    bof over 7 years
    What does "nonnegatable" mean?
  • mike
    mike over 7 years
    I was stuck between languages and just wrote some mixture, what I meant was nonnegligible.
  • T. Eskin
    T. Eskin about 7 years
    Positive and nonnegative are not the same though, as 'nonnegative' implies zero or positive, while 'positive' only implies positive.
  • Antonio Hernandez Maquivar
    Antonio Hernandez Maquivar about 7 years
    I did not know this. I have always taken zero to be a positive whole even number.
  • Roberto Rastapopoulos
    Roberto Rastapopoulos over 4 years
    @AntonioHernandezMaquivar This is just a convention. In French positive also includes zero, and I suppose the same holds for Spanish?
  • Antonio Hernandez Maquivar
    Antonio Hernandez Maquivar over 4 years
    @RobertoRastapopoulos I was taught that in school, yes. Is there a sound mathematical reason why $0$ would not be a positive number ?