Ph · Physics

Is the Retentivity of Soft Iron Greater Than That of Steel?

Published By the 9to5Science editorial team

At a glance

  1. 1. Define retentivity

    Retentivity describes how much magnetization remains after the magnetizing field is removed.

  2. 2. Compare typical materials

    Soft iron usually has lower retentivity than steel, so it loses more magnetization when the field is switched off.

  3. 3. Check the material and conditions

    Exact values depend on the iron or steel grade, its treatment, and how it was magnetized.

Advertisement

No. In the usual textbook comparison, soft iron has less retentivity than steel. After an external magnetic field is removed, soft iron generally retains less magnetization, whereas steel generally retains more. This is why soft iron is a traditional example of a material for temporary magnets and steel a traditional example for permanent magnets. Modern transformer cores and permanent magnets commonly use specialized materials rather than pure soft iron or ordinary steel.

The comparison is a general one, not a guarantee about every iron and steel alloy. Retentivity depends on composition, heat treatment, mechanical stress, and the magnetic field history of the sample.

What retentivity means

A ferromagnetic material becomes magnetized when placed in a magnetic field. When that applied field is reduced to zero, some magnetization may remain. Retentivity describes the material’s ability to retain this magnetization. In conventional hysteresis terminology, the remaining magnetic induction at zero applied field after a specified magnetizing history is called the remanent induction, or remanence, and is often denoted by BrB_r. Residual magnetization, often denoted by MrM_r, is a related but distinct quantity.

The terms retentivity and remanence are often used together in elementary explanations; some texts use retentivity for the magnitude of remanence. More precisely, remanence is the residual magnetic state measured after a specified magnetizing history, while retentivity describes the material’s tendency to retain it. The result depends on how strongly and in which direction the material was magnetized.

Why soft iron and steel behave differently

The difference is connected to how easily magnetic domains—the regions in which many atomic magnetic moments align—can change direction or move their boundaries.

In soft iron, domain walls can move relatively readily. It is therefore easy to magnetize, but it is also comparatively easy for the domains to rearrange when the applied field is removed. Its residual magnetization is usually modest. This behavior is useful in electromagnets, which should respond to a changing current and lose much of their magnetization when the current is switched off. Transformer cores also need soft magnetic materials with low coercivity and low hysteresis losses; modern cores commonly use electrical steel, ferrites, or other specialized materials rather than pure soft iron.

In many steels, domain-wall motion is more strongly hindered by the material’s composition and microstructure. Once magnetized, the domain arrangement is harder to undo, so more magnetization remains when the external field is removed. That higher retentivity is useful in traditional examples of permanent magnets. Modern permanent magnets, however, are typically made from specialized alloys or compounds.

A material’s resistance to being demagnetized is also described by coercivity. In the usual hysteresis-curve convention, coercivity HcH_c is the magnitude of the reverse field needed to bring the magnetic induction BB to zero after magnetization. The reverse field needed to bring the magnetization MM to zero is called the intrinsic coercivity, HciH_{ci}. Retentivity and coercivity are related features of hysteresis, but they are not the same property. A material can be discussed in terms of both how much magnetization remains and how hard it is to remove.

A practical comparison

Imagine placing a soft-iron bar and a steel bar in the same magnetizing field, then removing the field. In the usual classroom comparison:

MaterialTypical behavior after the field is removedCommon use
Soft ironRetains relatively little magnetizationElectromagnets; soft magnetic cores
SteelRetains relatively more magnetizationTraditional permanent magnets; modern permanent magnets usually use specialized materials

The table describes typical behavior, not a universal ranking for every possible alloy. The word “steel” covers many materials, and specially designed soft magnetic alloys can behave differently from ordinary steels.

Common mistakes

  • Confusing ease of magnetization with retentivity. Soft iron is easy to magnetize, but that does not mean it retains magnetization well. Ease of magnetization and retention after the field is removed are different characteristics.
  • Treating retentivity and coercivity as synonyms. Retentivity concerns the residual magnetization; coercivity concerns the reverse field needed to erase it.
  • Assuming every steel has the same magnetic properties. Alloy composition and processing matter. “Steel has greater retentivity” is the standard general comparison with soft iron, not a claim that every steel grade must exceed every iron-based material under every test.
  • Ignoring magnetic history. A sample’s remanence depends on the field it experienced. To compare materials fairly, magnetize them under specified, comparable conditions and measure them using the same method.

When the distinction matters

For an electromagnet, a soft-iron core is often preferred because it magnetizes strongly while current flows and loses much of its magnetization when the current is switched off. Transformer cores use soft magnetic materials chosen for properties such as low coercivity and low hysteresis losses. For a permanent magnet, high retentivity is desirable because the material should continue producing a magnetic field without an applied current; high coercivity also helps it resist demagnetization. In applications, engineers consider saturation magnetization, losses, temperature, and mechanical properties—not retentivity alone.

References

  1. Introduction to Magnetic Materials, 2nd ed., B. D. Cullity and C. D. Graham

Spotted an error? Send a correction. Read how we write and check articles in our editorial policy.