Christoffel Symbols in Terms of $\sqrt{|g|}$
At a glance
- 1. Identify the contraction
The determinant formula applies to the contracted Christoffel symbols, not to each individual symbol.
- 2. Use Jacobi’s formula
Differentiate the metric determinant to obtain the contracted connection.
- 3. Apply the identity
The result is the derivative of the logarithm of the metric volume factor.
- 4. Check with coordinates
Polar coordinates provide a concrete example where the formula gives the expected contraction.
The notation usually means the determinant of the metric tensor :
A standard identity relates the contracted Christoffel symbols to the metric volume factor:
For a positive-definite Riemannian metric, , so the absolute-value signs can be omitted. For a Lorentzian metric, is typically negative, and the invariant expression uses .
This is a formula for the contraction over one upper and one lower index. It is not a formula for every individual .
Derivation from the Christoffel formula
For the Levi-Civita connection,
Set and sum over :
The first and third terms cancel after relabeling the dummy indices and . Therefore,
Now use Jacobi’s determinant identity:
Consequently,
The last equality follows because, away from a degenerate metric,
For a Levi-Civita connection, the lower indices are symmetric:
Thus the equivalent contraction
has the same value.
Worked example: polar coordinates
The Euclidean plane has metric
In coordinates , the metric matrix is
For ,
The determinant formula gives
and
Direct calculation gives the nonzero Christoffel symbols
Therefore,
in agreement with the determinant formula.
Relation to divergence
The identity is especially useful when writing the divergence of a vector field . By definition,
Substitute the determinant expression:
Combining the terms gives the coordinate-invariant volume-element form
The corresponding volume element is
This explains geometrically why appears: it converts coordinate volume into metric volume.
What the formula does not tell you
Knowing alone is generally insufficient to reconstruct all Christoffel symbols. The determinant provides only one scalar function, whereas the metric contains many independent components. Different metrics can have the same determinant but different connections.
For example, in two dimensions, the metrics
both have determinant , but the first generally has nonzero Christoffel symbols when is nonconstant, while the second has zero Christoffel symbols in Cartesian coordinates.
To calculate an individual symbol, use
The compact formula is therefore best understood as a formula for the contracted connection and as a convenient route to divergence and volume-element identities.
References
- General Relativity, Robert M. Wald
- Riemannian Geometry, Manfredo P. do Carmo
Spotted an error? Send a correction. Read how we write and check articles in our editorial policy.