Why would a polar protic solvent favor the addition of HBr to an alkene?

1,848

Solution 1

why a protic solvent?

Protic solvents tend to have higher dielectric constants than typical, unreactive, non-protic solvents. Look at the following table.

\begin{array}{|c|c|c|}\hline \text{Solvent} & \text{Dielectric constant} \\ \hline \text{methanol} & 32.6 \\ \hline \text{ethanol} & 24.6 \\ \hline \text{methylene chloride} & 9.08 \\ \hline \text{chlorobenzene} & 5.69\\ \hline \text{chloroform} & 4.81 \\ \hline \text{diethyl ether} & 4.27 \\ \hline \end{array}

The higher dielectric constant stabilizes ions which means that 1) $\ce{HBr}$ will tend to be more dissociated and 2) (as Dissenter noted) the resultant carbocation intermediate will be more stabilized thereby lowering the energy of the transition state leading to it.

Solution 2

A polar protic solvent will help stabilize the carbocation that is formed in the process of electrophilic addition. When the nucleophilic $\pi$ bond grabs the hydrogen from the $\ce{HBr}$, one of the carbons that was part of the $\pi$ bond is left deficient of an octet.

Solution 3

High-dielectric solvent assist dissociation because they shield charge. Since the proton's electric field is so high, it always finds a base to bind to, which will in your case be $\ce{Br-}$. So you also have to consider the solvent's basicity. Read this article.

The assertion that you need a protic solvent is wrong, you need a sufficiently basic solvent.

Share:
1,848
yolo123
Author by

yolo123

Updated on August 01, 2022

Comments

  • yolo123
    yolo123 over 1 year

    I understand that a polar solvent will help dissociate the $\ce{HBr}$ into ions.

    But why a protic solvent?

    Why would we want a solvent that would encage the $\ce{Br}$ and $\ce{H}$ ions?

    Why is the aprotic solvent not favored? My textbook does not discuss this and I searched online, with no result.

  • Abel Friedman
    Abel Friedman about 9 years
    Propylene carbonate: 64; Acetonitrile: 39; dimethylformamide: 38; HMPT: 30
  • ron
    ron about 9 years
    @AbelFriedman That's why I highlighted unreactive. I don't know the reaction conditions we're discussing, but acid-catalyzed hydration of a nitrile would be a distinct possibility.
  • yolo123
    yolo123 about 9 years
    @AbelFriedman, (and @Dissenter), ron seems to agree with my textbook like Dissenter. I'm confused :O
  • ron
    ron about 9 years
    @AbelFriedman Yes, propylene carbonate, DMF and HMPT are also subject to acid hydrolysis and could generate by-products that would contaminate the reaction.