Ph · Physics

What Is the Difference Between d|v|/dt and |dv/dt|?

Published By the 9to5Science editorial team

At a glance

  1. 1. Identify the quantity

    The derivative of a magnitude is a signed rate of change; the magnitude of a derivative is nonnegative.

  2. 2. Use the dot product

    For a nonzero vector, the rate of change of its magnitude is the component of its derivative along the vector.

  3. 3. Compare the meanings

    For velocity, these are tangential acceleration and total acceleration; for position, they are radial velocity and speed.

  4. 4. Check zero values

    At zero magnitude, the usual formula may not apply, and the magnitude may not be differentiable.

Advertisement

The notation changes meaning depending on whether you take a derivative first or a magnitude first. If v(t)\mathbf{v}(t) is a velocity vector, then d∣v∣/dtd|\mathbf{v}|/dt is the signed rate at which speed changes. By contrast, ∣dv/dt∣|d\mathbf{v}/dt| is the magnitude of acceleration. They are generally not equal.

The same distinction applies to position: the derivative of distance from the origin is not generally the same as the magnitude of velocity. The key is whether you want a rate along one direction or the total magnitude of a vector.

The derivative of a vector’s magnitude

For a differentiable, nonzero vector q(t)\mathbf{q}(t),

d∣q∣dt=q⋅q˙∣q∣.\frac{d|\mathbf{q}|}{dt}=\frac{\mathbf{q}\cdot\dot{\mathbf{q}}}{|\mathbf{q}|}.

This follows by differentiating ∣q∣=q⋅q|\mathbf{q}|=\sqrt{\mathbf{q}\cdot\mathbf{q}}. The dot product selects the part of q˙\dot{\mathbf{q}} in the direction of q\mathbf{q}. So the derivative of the magnitude is a signed component, not the full magnitude of the vector’s derivative.

In general,

∣dqdt∣≥∣d∣q∣dt∣.\left|\frac{d\mathbf{q}}{dt}\right| \geq \left|\frac{d|\mathbf{q}|}{dt}\right|.

Equality holds when q˙\dot{\mathbf{q}} is parallel or antiparallel to q\mathbf{q} (assuming q≠0\mathbf{q}\ne\mathbf{0}). If the vector changes direction as well as magnitude, the full derivative can be larger.

Applying this to velocity

Let v\mathbf{v} be velocity and a=dv/dt\mathbf{a}=d\mathbf{v}/dt acceleration. Since speed is ∣v∣|\mathbf{v}|,

d∣v∣dt=v⋅a∣v∣,∣dvdt∣=∣a∣.\frac{d|\mathbf{v}|}{dt}=\frac{\mathbf{v}\cdot\mathbf{a}}{|\mathbf{v}|}, \qquad \left|\frac{d\mathbf{v}}{dt}\right|=|\mathbf{a}|.

The first quantity is the signed tangential acceleration: it is positive when the speed increases, negative when the speed decreases, and zero when acceleration is perpendicular to velocity. The second is the total acceleration magnitude, which also includes any component that changes the direction of motion.

Worked example

Suppose at an instant

v=(3,4) m/s,a=(4,0) m/s2.\mathbf{v}=(3,4)\ \text{m/s}, \qquad \mathbf{a}=(4,0)\ \text{m/s}^2.

The speed is ∣v∣=5 m/s|\mathbf{v}|=5\ \text{m/s}. Therefore,

d∣v∣dt=(3,4)⋅(4,0)5=125=2.4 m/s2.\frac{d|\mathbf{v}|}{dt} =\frac{(3,4)\cdot(4,0)}{5} =\frac{12}{5} =2.4\ \text{m/s}^2.

But the acceleration magnitude is

∣dvdt∣=∣a∣=4 m/s2.\left|\frac{d\mathbf{v}}{dt}\right|=|\mathbf{a}|=4\ \text{m/s}^2.

The speed is increasing at 2.4 m/s2.4\ \text{m/s} each second, while the total acceleration has magnitude 4 m/s24\ \text{m/s}^2. The difference comes from acceleration perpendicular to the direction of travel, which changes direction without contributing to the instantaneous speed increase.

Applying this to position

For a position vector r\mathbf{r}, its magnitude ∣r∣|\mathbf{r}| is distance from the origin, and dr/dt=vd\mathbf{r}/dt=\mathbf{v}. Thus, when r≠0\mathbf{r}\ne\mathbf{0},

d∣r∣dt=r⋅v∣r∣,∣drdt∣=∣v∣.\frac{d|\mathbf{r}|}{dt}=\frac{\mathbf{r}\cdot\mathbf{v}}{|\mathbf{r}|}, \qquad \left|\frac{d\mathbf{r}}{dt}\right|=|\mathbf{v}|.

The first is the signed rate at which the object’s distance from the origin changes (radial velocity). The second is its speed. In the numerical example above, if r=(3,4) m\mathbf{r}=(3,4)\ \text{m} and v=(4,0) m/s\mathbf{v}=(4,0)\ \text{m/s}, then the distance from the origin increases at 12/5=2.4 m/s12/5=2.4\ \text{m/s}, while the speed is 4 m/s4\ \text{m/s}.

If xx is a one-dimensional position coordinate rather than a vector, then ∣x∣|x| is distance from the origin on that line. For x≠0x\ne0,

d∣x∣dt=sgn⁡(x)dxdt,∣dxdt∣=speed.\frac{d|x|}{dt}=\operatorname{sgn}(x)\frac{dx}{dt}, \qquad \left|\frac{dx}{dt}\right|=\text{speed}.

For example, at x=−5 mx=-5\ \text{m} with dx/dt=2 m/sdx/dt=2\ \text{m/s}, the object moves toward the origin: d∣x∣/dt=−2 m/sd|x|/dt=-2\ \text{m/s}, but its speed is ∣dx/dt∣=2 m/s|dx/dt|=2\ \text{m/s}. If instead x=5 mx=5\ \text{m} with the same velocity, its distance from the origin increases at 2 m/s2\ \text{m/s}.

Common mistakes

  • Treating a signed rate as a magnitude. A derivative such as d∣v∣/dtd|\mathbf{v}|/dt can be negative; a magnitude such as ∣a∣|\mathbf{a}| cannot.
  • Equating speed change with acceleration magnitude. They are equal only when acceleration points along or directly opposite velocity. In curved motion, acceleration can change direction without changing speed.
  • Forgetting what the origin means. d∣r∣/dtd|\mathbf{r}|/dt describes change in distance from a chosen origin, not necessarily change in distance from some other object.
  • Using the nonzero-vector formula at zero. The dot-product formula divides by ∣q∣|\mathbf{q}|, so it does not apply when q=0\mathbf{q}=\mathbf{0}. At zero speed or at the origin, the magnitude may have a corner and fail to be differentiable; check the motion directly.

References

  1. OpenStax, University Physics Volume 1

Spotted an error? Send a correction. Read how we write and check articles in our editorial policy.