What If a Reviewer Recommends Rejection but the Editor Requests Major Revision?
At a glance
- 1. Follow the decision letter
The editor’s decision governs the manuscript’s status, even when one reviewer recommends rejection.
- 2. Address every comment
Respond point by point, including the rejecting reviewer’s concerns, and explain any changes you cannot make.
- 3. Make the revision clear
Mark changes in the manuscript and provide a separate, courteous response document.
- 4. Treat revision as uncertain
A major-revision invitation is an opportunity for further consideration, not a promise of acceptance.
A reviewer’s recommendation to reject can appear alongside an editor’s decision to invite a major revision. This is not necessarily a mistake: reviewers advise, while the editor makes the journal’s decision after considering the reviews and the manuscript as a whole.
A major-revision decision means the editor is willing to consider a substantially revised version. It does not mean the paper has been accepted or that the rejection recommendation can be ignored. Your best next step is to use the decision letter as the guide and prepare a careful, point-by-point response.
Why the reviewer and editor may disagree
Reviewers assess a submission and recommend an outcome, but their recommendations are not votes that automatically determine the result. The editor is responsible for the decision and may weigh the reports differently.
For example, the rejecting reviewer may identify important but fixable weaknesses, while another reviewer is more positive. The editor may believe that revisions could address the concerns, or may judge that the paper has enough value to merit another round of review. Editors can also take the journal’s scope, standards, and the reviews’ reasoning into account.
The precise meaning of “major revision” varies between journals. In general, it signals substantial work before the editor can make a further decision. The editor may send the revision to the same reviewers, invite different reviewers, or assess it directly. None of these routes guarantees eventual acceptance.
What to do next
- Read the decision letter closely. Check what the editor explicitly asks you to do, the submission deadline, and whether the letter includes instructions for responding to reviewers. The editor’s decision—not an individual reviewer’s recommendation—is the status to act on.
- Answer every substantive comment. Include comments from the reviewer who recommended rejection. That reviewer’s concerns may be central to the editor’s decision, and the editor may expect to see how you handled them.
- Revise the manuscript where appropriate. Make changes that improve the work and address the criticism. Clearly mark or otherwise identify changes if the journal requests it.
- Explain disagreements professionally. If a reviewer’s point rests on a misunderstanding or you believe a suggested change would weaken the paper, explain why with evidence or a concise argument. Do not simply say that you disagree.
- Submit a response document. Quote or summarize each comment, then state what you changed and where. If you did not make a requested change, give a specific reason. Follow the journal’s formatting and resubmission instructions.
Worked example: responding to a rejection recommendation
Suppose Reviewer 2 recommends rejection because the study does not support its main claim. The editor nevertheless invites a major revision, and Reviewer 1 asks for clearer methods and additional analysis.
A productive response would not focus on the fact that the editor chose revision rather than rejection. Instead, examine Reviewer 2’s underlying concern. If the claim is too broad, narrow it in the abstract, results, and discussion. If the reviewer points to a missing analysis that is feasible, add it and report the result. Then explain precisely what changed and where.
If the requested analysis is not possible or would not answer the question, explain the limitation, support your reasoning, and consider whether the claim should be qualified instead. Address Reviewer 1’s comments as well. The editor needs to see that the revision deals with the manuscript’s weaknesses, not just the comments that seem easiest to answer.
A response might say: “We agree that the original wording overstated what the data establish. We have narrowed the claim in the abstract and discussion and added a limitation explaining that the study cannot establish causation (revised manuscript, pages 2 and 11).” This is more useful than a general statement that the comment has been considered.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Ignoring the rejecting reviewer. The editor’s revision invitation does not cancel that review. Leaving its main criticisms unanswered can make the revised submission look incomplete.
- Treating the decision as a promise. A major revision is not provisional acceptance. The editor may reject the paper after evaluating the revision.
- Responding defensively. Keep the tone factual and respectful, even if a comment seems mistaken or unfair. Explain your reasoning rather than criticizing the reviewer.
- Making changes without documenting them. A reviewer or editor should be able to find the revision quickly. Point to sections, pages, figures, or line numbers as appropriate.
- Guessing when instructions conflict. If the decision letter is unclear about whether a particular change is required, or its instructions appear inconsistent, ask the editor for clarification before resubmitting. If you need more time, request an extension early.
What happens after resubmission?
The editor reviews the revised manuscript and response. The paper may be accepted, receive another round of revision, or be rejected. If the editor sends it back to reviewers, a reviewer may still maintain the original recommendation or raise new concerns. Your response cannot guarantee a favorable outcome, but a thorough, transparent revision gives the editor a clear basis for deciding whether the concerns have been resolved.
If the editor’s letter explicitly says the paper is rejected rather than inviting revision, do not assume that a reviewer’s more positive report creates a right to resubmit. Follow the decision and any appeal or resubmission policy stated by the journal.
Spotted an error? Send a correction. Read how we write and check articles in our editorial policy.