How to Find the Volume Between a Sphere and a Paraboloid
At a glance
- 1. Write the surfaces
Use cylindrical coordinates for a sphere centered on the vertical axis and a rotational paraboloid.
- 2. Find the intersection
Set the surface heights equal to determine the outer radius of the bounded region.
- 3. Set up the volume
Integrate the upper surface minus the lower surface, including the cylindrical-coordinate factor r.
- 4. Evaluate and check
Substitute the intersection radius and confirm the volume is positive.
The volume depends on the sphere’s radius and the paraboloid’s equation, so the title alone does not determine a single numerical answer. A common setup is a sphere centered at the origin and an upward-opening paraboloid with its vertex at the origin. For that case, cylindrical coordinates reduce the volume calculation to a one-variable integral.
Set up the standard case
Suppose the surfaces are
and
In cylindrical coordinates, . The sphere’s upper hemisphere is , and the paraboloid is . The usual enclosed solid is above the paraboloid and below the upper hemisphere, from the axis out to where the surfaces meet.
The volume element is . The factor is the cylindrical-coordinate Jacobian; omitting it gives an incorrect volume.
Find the intersection radius
Set the two heights equal:
Both sides are nonnegative for the region under consideration, so squaring is valid. Let . Then
The positive solution gives the square of the intersection radius:
The volume is therefore
Integrating gives a convenient general expression:
You can use the intersection relation to simplify this further if desired.
Worked example
Find the volume between the sphere
and the paraboloid
Here and . At the intersection, writing gives
so the positive root is . Thus , and the surfaces meet at height .
Set up and evaluate the integral:
This is approximately cubic units. The integrand represents the vertical gap between the sphere and paraboloid at radius , multiplied by the cylindrical area factor and integrated over all angles.
Common mistakes
- Using the whole sphere as the upper surface: The relevant surface here is the upper hemisphere, . The lower hemisphere has negative and does not bound this particular solid above.
- Forgetting the Jacobian: In cylindrical coordinates, volume includes the factor . The integral is not just the height difference integrated with respect to .
- Integrating past the intersection: The radial limit is the radius where the surfaces meet, not automatically the sphere’s radius. Beyond the intersection, the order of the surfaces changes.
- Assuming the title fixes a numerical answer: A different sphere center, radius, or paraboloid equation changes both the bounds and the volume. Write the actual equations first, then identify which bounded region is intended.
If your equations differ
For a shifted sphere or a paraboloid with a different vertex or axis, first express both surfaces as heights over a common projection plane, if possible. Find their intersection curve, determine which surface is above the other on the chosen region, and integrate their difference with the correct area element. If the solid is bounded by a different part of the sphere or includes multiple pieces, its bounds must be adjusted accordingly.
References
- James Stewart, Calculus: Early Transcendentals
Spotted an error? Send a correction. Read how we write and check articles in our editorial policy.