The sum of all the odd numbers to infinity
Solution 1
Since $$ \zeta(z)=\sum_{k=1}^\infty\frac1{k^{\large z}} $$ and $$ 2^{{\large z}}\zeta(z)=\sum_{k=1}^\infty\frac1{(2k)^{\large z}} $$ we have $$ \left(12^{{\large z}}\right)\zeta(z)=\sum_{k=1}^\infty\frac1{(2k1)^{\large z}} $$ Thus, the same reasoning that says $$ \sum_{k=1}^\infty k=\zeta(1)=\frac1{12} $$ would say that $$ \sum_{k=1}^\infty2k=2\zeta(1)=\frac16 $$ and $$ \sum_{k=1}^\infty(2k1)=(12)\zeta(1)=\frac1{12} $$ Taking the difference of these last two, would lead one to conclude that $$ \sum_{k=1}^\infty1=\frac14 $$ not $\infty$.
When dealing with divergent series, as with quantum mechanics, things are not always the way one would expect.
Solution 2
If you start by accepting that in some sense $1+2+3+\ldots=\frac1{12}$ instead of diverging, you should also not assume a priori that $(1)+(1)+(1)+\ldots =\infty$. Instead, for a consistant summation method that assigns values to $S_1=1+2+3+\ldots$ and to $S_3=1+3+5+\ldots$ and to $S_2=2+4+6+\ldots$ and that allows the manipulations you used (multiply by a constant factor, add summandwise, partition), we must have $1+1+1+\ldots = 2S_2S_3$ and $S_2=2S_1$ and $S_1=S_2+S_3$, hence $S_3=S_1$ and $1+1+1+\ldots = 5S_1$ ($\ne\infty$ if $S_1\ne\infty$). You can't use the standard summation (limit of partial sums) in one part of your argument and another summation in other parts.
Solution 3
S1 is divergent series. It doesn't have a finite sum and this possibility of rearranging terms in order to get different sums is a consequence of that. An issue should be immediately apparent once you see a monotonically increasing series of nonnegative terms converging to a negative number.
Related videos on Youtube
It'sRainingMen
Updated on August 10, 2022Comments

It'sRainingMen about 1 year
We have this sequence:
S1: 1+2+3+4+5+6.. (to infinity)
It has been demonstrated, that S1 = 1/12.
Now, what happens if i multiply by a factor of 2?
S2: 2+4+6+8+10+12.... (to infinity).
I have 2S1, which is equal to 1/6
On this, we can create a equation for the odd numbers:
S3: 1+3+5+5+7+9+11... (to infinity)
We know that for every term in S2, every term in S3 is just (n1)
Or, The sum of the even numbers, Minus , the sum of infinitely many (1)s
So S3 = 1/6  ∞
However, we also know that the odd numbers + the even numbers = The natural numbers.
So let's try it.
1/6  (1/6 ∞)
We have 1/6 + 1/6 + ∞
Which is just ∞
So, there we have it. a paradox. S1 cannot be both 1/12 or ∞