Tetrahedron volume in the first octant

2,518

So you came up with a formula which is (with very little rearrangement) $$V = \frac{(xyz)^2}{2}+2 xyz+\frac{(xyz)^3}{24}+\frac83,$$ and you know from the very beginning that $$xyz = 2.$$ Having those two pieces of information, you are a very short step away from the solution. You should be able to use a simple substitution to find the numeric value of the first formula. The second formula tells you a substitution you can use.

I don't know exactly how you got the first formula; a comparison to a more general formula for $xyz = c,$ where $c$ is an arbitrary positive constant, makes me think you already used the specific fact that $xyz = 2.$ (Which is perfectly OK, because you were given that fact in the problem statement.) Since the resulting volume for $xyz = 2$ agrees with the general solution, however, I don't see any reason to suspect that you made any errors.

You can also look at the solutions and links mentioned in Show that product of x, y, and z intercents of tangent plane to surface xyz=1 is a constant. Your question is almost a duplicate of that one (up to a constant factor), except that you had gotten much closer to a solution at the point where you asked your question.

Share:
2,518

Related videos on Youtube

John
Author by

John

Updated on May 23, 2020

Comments

  • John
    John over 3 years

    The surface is given:

    $xyz = 2$

    It is in the first octant so $x > 0, y > 0, z > 0$.

    The tangent plane taken at any point of this surface binds with the coordinate axes to form a tetrahedron.

    Task: prove that the volume of the solid is not dependent on the chosen point and calculate the volume.

    I used the approximation formula to derive the tangent plane equation in the form $z-z_0 = \frac{d}{dx}(x-x_0)+\frac{d}{dy}(y-y_0)$. From this, I tried to calculate the volume with $V = \frac{1}{3}A_{base}\times height \,of\, tetrahedron$ (I tried to get the points of intersection with the axes and derive tetrahedron side lengths).

    But in the end I come to the following: $0.5(zxy)^2+2zxy+\frac{1}{24}(zxy)^3+\frac{8}{3} = V$, where $x, y, z$ are just the coordinate of the point chosen for the tangent plane on the surface. And it does not seem to simplify to some universal constant. Moreover, it does not even seem that all tetrahedrons bound by tangent planes for this surface in the first octant are equal in volume.

    How can I prove the task and find the volume? Any suggestions?

  • John
    John almost 9 years
    OMG =)) You are right. I in fact got to this by getting first derivatives from xyz=2 and combining them into the equation of the plane. In fact these xyz - they are x0y0z0 which denote the point at which the tangent to the surface is given. the unknown xy for the plane got eliminated in the simplification. I somehow got confused because I already used the xyz=2 at the beginning to derive first derivatives for the tangent plane and didnt realize they come to the same constant because it lies on the surface =) Thank you =)