Is this animated gif an accurate representation of EM waves?

4,097

Solution 1

These look like TE waves in a rectangular waveguide. The electric field, magnetic field and the direction of propagation form a mutually orthogonal set (TEM wave) in free space propagation , not necessarily in guided waves. In fact, one can show from Maxwell's equations that a single conductor waveguide cannot support a single one of those TEM waves you are talking about. These structures support TE and TM waves, which have magnetic and electric fields along the propagation direction, respectively.

The fields in that gif are the TE10 mode of a rectangular waveguide which look like this:

enter image description here
(Image from Field and Wave Electromagnetics by D.k.Cheng)

Solution 2

I believe that is a visualization of a wave confined to a waveguide, not travelling in free space. This mode is called a TE mode of the waveguide because the E field is perpendicular to the axis of the waveguide but the H field is not.

Because the field goes to zero beyond certain boundaries in the transverse direction, we can guess this is meant to be a wave travelling in a waveguide with perfectly conducting boundaries (as opposed to, for example, a dielectric waveguide).

The reason the H field is not perpendicular to the overall direction of power flow is that there is essentially a superposition of two waves here, one zig-zagging left and right across the waveguide and the other zig-zagging right and left.

Share:
4,097

Related videos on Youtube

Bergi
Author by

Bergi

Updated on August 01, 2022

Comments

  • Bergi
    Bergi 17 days

    From multiple sources, I learned that, in EM waves, electric field vectors are perpendicular to magnetic field vectors and both are perdendicular to the direction of propagation. On this gif, which claims it’s a visual representation of EM waves, electric and magnetic fields are perpendicular to each other, but the magnetic vectors are not always perpendicular to the direction of propagation, describing “circles”.

    So, is it an accurate representation still? Am I missing something?

    • The Photon
      The Photon almost 5 years
      It looks like that's a visualization of an EM wave travelling in some kind of waveguide structure, not in free space. Do you have any context about what it's supposed to be?
    • The Photon
      The Photon almost 5 years
      It looks like a TE mode.
    • Admin
      Admin almost 5 years
      Not much unfortunately. Found it here, physics.stackexchange.com/questions/156606/… — right on the second answer if I’m not wrong. The person provided the link
    • Admin
      Admin almost 5 years
      Well, at least I guess it’s not a conventional EM wave right? I’ll try to understand what a TE mode is from the article you posted
    • The Photon
      The Photon almost 5 years
      Sorry it's not actually a very good article. If you google you might find some much better resources (or get a good E&M textbook like Ramo, Whinnery, & Van Duzer (and a 4th guy in later editions))